Mack Natasha, Robinson Elizabeth T, MacQueen Kathleen M, Moffett Jill, Johnson Laura M
Family Health International, P.O. Box 13950, Research Triangle Park, NC 27709, USA.
J Empir Res Hum Res Ethics. 2010 Jun;5(2):3-19. doi: 10.1525/jer.2010.5.2.3.
media coverage influences how clinical trials are perceived internationally and in communities where trials occur, affecting recruitment, retention, and political support for research. We conducted a discourse analysis of news coverage from 2004-2005 of a trial in Cameroon on oral PrEP for HIV prevention, to identify messages, communication techniques, and sources of messages that were amplified via media. We identified two parallel discourses: one on ethical concerns about the Cameroon trial, and a second, more general "science exploitation" discourse concerned with the potential for trials with vulnerable participant populations to be conducted unethically, benefiting only wealthy populations. Researchers should overtly address exploitation as an integral, ongoing component of research, particularly where historical or cultural conditions set the stage for controversy to emerge.
媒体报道会影响国际上以及开展试验的社区对临床试验的看法,进而影响招募、留存以及对研究的政治支持。我们对2004年至2005年喀麦隆一项关于口服预防艾滋病病毒暴露前预防(PrEP)试验的新闻报道进行了话语分析,以确定通过媒体放大的信息、传播技巧和信息来源。我们识别出两种并行的话语:一种是关于喀麦隆试验的伦理问题,另一种是更普遍的“科学剥削”话语,涉及对弱势群体进行试验可能存在不道德行为,仅使富裕人群受益。研究人员应公开将剥削作为研究不可或缺的持续组成部分来处理,特别是在历史或文化条件引发争议的情况下。