Department of Dental Materials Science, Academic Centre for Dentistry Amsterdam (ACTA), Universiteit van Amsterdam en VrijeUniversiteit, The Netherlands.
J Dent. 2010;38 Suppl 2:e50-6. doi: 10.1016/j.jdent.2010.07.004. Epub 2010 Jul 16.
A newly developed system for color determination and reproduction is logically arranged and systematically combines a few components to acquire its broad color range. The objective was to evaluate color coverage of human teeth with the range of the new system and to compare it with other existing systems.
The systems for color determination used in this study were: New system Standard (NS), New system Expanded (NE), Vita Classical (VC) and Vita 3D-Master (V3D) (Vita Zahnfabriek, Germany), Vintage Halo (VH) (Shofu, Japan), Chromascope (CH) (Ivoclar Vivadent, Lichtenstein). The tabs of all systems were measured with digital spectrophotometer, SpectroShade-Micro (MHT, Italy), and their Lab* values were compared with the Lab* values of 198 teeth (mean age=30.10; SD=13.15) to obtain their coverage errors. The ΔE≤1.6 was established as threshold for perceptibility.
Wilcoxon-signed rank test showed that the coverage of the teeth with the NE range was the best, as indicated by the lowest mean minimal ΔE value, followed by the NS range. Both ranges had statistically significant lower mean minimal ΔE values than all the other systems (p>0.01). The percentage of ΔE≤1.6 was significantly higher for NS and NE range than for the other systems (p>0.01).
The newly developed color determination and color reproduction system could cover the range of human teeth, used in this study, below the level of perceptibility (ΔE≤1.6) better than four other available contemporary systems.
新开发的颜色确定和再现系统逻辑上进行了布置,并系统地组合了几个组件,以获得其广泛的色域。目的是评估新系统的色域对人牙颜色的覆盖范围,并将其与其他现有系统进行比较。
本研究中使用的颜色确定系统有:新系统标准版(NS)、新系统扩展版(NE)、Vita 经典版(VC)和 Vita 3D-Master(V3D)(德国 Vita Zahnfabrik)、Vintage Halo(VH)(日本 Shofu)、Chromascope(CH)(义获嘉伟瓦登特,列支敦士登)。所有系统的色标均用数字分光光度计 SpectroShade-Micro(MHT,意大利)进行测量,并将其 Lab值与 198 颗牙齿(平均年龄=30.10;SD=13.15)的 Lab值进行比较,以获得其覆盖误差。将 ΔE≤1.6 设定为可感知性的阈值。
Wilcoxon 符号秩检验表明,NE 范围的牙齿覆盖效果最好,表现为最小平均 ΔE 值最低,其次是 NS 范围。这两个范围的最小平均 ΔE 值均显著低于其他所有系统(p>0.01)。NS 和 NE 范围的 ΔE≤1.6 的百分比显著高于其他系统(p>0.01)。
与其他四个现有的当代系统相比,新开发的颜色确定和颜色再现系统可以更好地覆盖本研究中使用的人牙范围,低于可感知性(ΔE≤1.6)水平。