Department of Dermatology, School of Medicine, Emory University, 101 Woodruff Circle, Atlanta, GA 30322, USA.
Melanoma Res. 2010 Oct;20(5):417-21. doi: 10.1097/CMR.0b013e32833d327b.
The primary objective of our study was to update the prevalence of total body photography (TBP) utilization and the rationale for its implementation as an adjunctive screening measure by academic dermatologists across the USA, and investigate the emergence of total body digital photography (TBDP). Our secondary objective was to further examine how TBP/TBDP is being incorporated into the dermatology screening examination in academic pigmented lesion clinics. A questionnaire was mailed to 113 dermatology departments across the USA. About 43% (49/113) of surveyed departments responded. TBP was used by 67% (33/49) of the respondents. Of these respondents, 33% (11/33) used TBDP alone, 33% (11/33) used TBDP in combination with nondigitally based TBP, and 33% (11/33) used nondigital TBP with print photos. The three most frequently cited reasons for the use of full-body baseline photographs were that they reduced patient anxiety, led to fewer biopsies, and helped to find melanoma early in the curable stage. Respondents who did not use full body baseline photographs cited logistical constraints as the number one reason, followed by perceived lack of utility. In conclusion, our study shows that there is a significant number of academic dermatologists using TBP/TBDP. However, this study also shows that there are conflicting beliefs among academic dermatologists concerning the efficacy of TBP/TBDP. At this point with a documented growing trend in utilization of TBP, more studies are needed to evaluate the efficacy of this screening adjunct to diagnose melanoma early and positively impact survival because of early diagnosis.
我们研究的主要目的是更新美国学术皮肤科医生使用全身摄影(TBP)的流行率及其作为辅助筛查手段的原理,并研究全身数字摄影(TBDP)的出现。我们的次要目的是进一步研究 TBP/TBDP 如何被纳入学术色素病变诊所的皮肤科筛查检查。我们向美国的 113 个皮肤科部门邮寄了一份问卷。大约 43%(49/113)的被调查部门做出了回应。67%(33/49)的受访者使用了 TBP。在这些受访者中,33%(11/33)单独使用 TBDP,33%(11/33)将 TBDP 与非数字 TBP 结合使用,33%(11/33)使用非数字 TBP 并打印照片。使用全身基线照片的三个最常见的原因是它们降低了患者的焦虑,减少了活检数量,并有助于在可治愈阶段早期发现黑色素瘤。不使用全身基线照片的受访者将后勤限制列为首要原因,其次是认为缺乏实用性。总之,我们的研究表明,有相当数量的学术皮肤科医生使用 TBP/TBDP。然而,这项研究还表明,学术皮肤科医生对 TBP/TBDP 的疗效存在矛盾的看法。在目前 TBP 利用率呈增长趋势的情况下,需要更多的研究来评估这种筛查辅助手段诊断早期黑色素瘤和积极影响生存的疗效,因为早期诊断。