Siu Stanton T, Udaltsova Natalia, Iribarren Carlos, Klatsky Arthur L
Department of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine, Oakland Medical Center, CA, USA.
Perm J. 2010 Spring;14(1):11-8. doi: 10.7812/TPP/09-089.
Limited data suggest that moderate alcohol drinkers may have better lung airways function than abstainers. Because few studies have fully accounted for confounders (including smoking and coronary disease), and some might have been biased by the inclusion with nondrinkers of alcohol drinkers who quit because of illness, we performed a cross-sectional analysis in a large free-living population.
We studied the relation between alcohol and airways function in 177,721 members of a comprehensive health plan. An item on a questionnaire administered as part of a health examination asked for "usual number of drinks in the past year." Respondents were asked to lump "wine, beer, whiskey, and cocktails" together. Health history queries included 47 items indicative of possible cardiorespiratory (CR) illness; participants with one or more positive response (61.0%) were classified as "CR yes." Lung function measurements were part of the health examination; we studied one-second forced expiratory volume (FEV(1)), forced vital capacity (FVC), and FEV(1)/FVC by analysis of covariance and FEV(1)/FVC <0.7 by logistic regression. Nondrinkers were the referent for alcohol categories; covariates were age, sex, ethnicity, smoking, education, body mass index, and CR composite yes/no.
For each measure studied, persons reporting two or fewer drinks per day or three to five drinks per day had better airways function than nondrinkers (p < 0.001), but heavier drinkers had worse function. This J-shaped relation was consistent across multiple strata, including CR "yes" or "no."
Independent of smoking and evident lung or heart disease, light to moderate drinkers of alcohol had better FEV(1), FVC, and FEV(1)/FVC than abstainers did. Although this association does not prove causality, drinking moderate amounts of alcoholic beverages may have some benefit for lung function.
有限的数据表明,适量饮酒者的肺气道功能可能优于戒酒者。由于很少有研究充分考虑混杂因素(包括吸烟和冠心病),而且一些研究可能因将因疾病而戒酒的饮酒者纳入不饮酒者中而存在偏差,我们在一大群自由生活的人群中进行了一项横断面分析。
我们研究了177721名综合健康计划成员中酒精与气道功能之间的关系。作为健康检查一部分的问卷中的一个项目询问了“过去一年中通常饮酒的次数”。受访者被要求将“葡萄酒、啤酒、威士忌和鸡尾酒”归为一类。健康史询问包括47项表明可能存在心肺(CR)疾病的项目;有一项或多项阳性反应的参与者(61.0%)被归类为“CR阳性”。肺功能测量是健康检查的一部分;我们通过协方差分析研究了一秒用力呼气量(FEV(1))、用力肺活量(FVC)和FEV(1)/FVC,并通过逻辑回归研究了FEV(1)/FVC<0.7的情况。不饮酒者是酒精类别比较的参照对象;协变量包括年龄、性别、种族、吸烟情况、教育程度、体重指数以及CR综合情况(阳性/阴性)。
对于所研究的各项指标,报告每天饮酒两杯或更少或每天饮酒三到五杯的人比不饮酒者的气道功能更好(p<0.001),但饮酒量更大者的功能更差。这种J形关系在多个分层中都是一致的,包括CR“阳性”或“阴性”。
在不考虑吸烟以及明显的肺部或心脏疾病的情况下,轻度至中度饮酒者的FEV(1)、FVC和FEV(1)/FVC比戒酒者更好。尽管这种关联并不能证明因果关系,但饮用适量酒精饮料可能对肺功能有一定益处。