Institute of Applied Informatics, Cracow University of Technology, Al. Jana Pawła II 37, 31-864 Cracow, Poland.
Med Eng Phys. 2011 Mar;33(2):218-25. doi: 10.1016/j.medengphy.2010.10.005. Epub 2010 Nov 2.
According to the standard approach, estimation of the structure model index (SMI) of a trabecular bone sample has to be preceded by segmentation of the bone image and then triangulation of the trabecular surface. However, when analyzing clinical data, image segmentation should be avoided whenever possible, due to difficulties in controlling binarization artifacts. The aim of the present study is to develop a method to estimate SMI directly from gray-level images, without prior segmentation. It is shown that the standard definition of SMI can be formulated in terms of integrals of the gray-level intensity and the magnitude of the gray-level intensity gradient, computed for the analyzed image and the image eroded by an infinitesimal ball structuring element. Because in a real application the size of an eroding element is always finite, a procedure is proposed to reduce the finite size errors. The performance of the proposed method is tested for structures with known SMI. Next, based on a set of μCT images of trabecular bone from the distal radius, the proposed and the standard methods are compared. It is shown that the proposed novel approach is statistically equivalent to the standard one, if applied to high-resolution μCT data. The influence of clinically relevant factors like limited resolution and noise on the estimation of SMI is tested. It is shown that the gray-level approach is more robust against image degradation factors than the standard one.
根据标准方法,对小梁骨样本的结构模型指数 (SMI) 进行估计,必须先对骨图像进行分割,然后对小梁表面进行三角剖分。然而,在分析临床数据时,由于难以控制二值化伪影,应尽可能避免图像分割。本研究的目的是开发一种无需事先分割即可直接从灰度图像估计 SMI 的方法。结果表明,可以根据分析图像和经过无穷小球结构元素侵蚀的图像的灰度强度和灰度强度梯度的幅度积分来定义 SMI 的标准定义。由于在实际应用中侵蚀元素的大小总是有限的,因此提出了一种减小有限尺寸误差的方法。为具有已知 SMI 的结构测试了所提出方法的性能。接下来,基于来自远端桡骨的小梁骨 μCT 图像集,比较了所提出的方法和标准方法。结果表明,如果将高分辨率 μCT 数据应用于标准方法,则所提出的新方法在统计学上等同于标准方法。测试了对 SMI 估计有影响的临床相关因素,如有限的分辨率和噪声。结果表明,灰度方法比标准方法对图像退化因素更具鲁棒性。