Department of Neurosurgery, UCLA Medical Center, West Los Angeles Veteran's Administration Hospital, Los Angeles, CA, USA.
Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2011 Sep 1;81(1):225-31. doi: 10.1016/j.ijrobp.2010.05.058. Epub 2011 Jan 13.
Dedicated linear accelerator radiosurgery (D-LINAC) has become an important treatment for trigeminal neuralgia (TN). Although the use of gamma knife continues to be established, few large series exist using D-LINAC. The authors describe their results, comparing the effects of varied target and dose regimens.
Between August 1995 and January 2008, 179 patients were treated with D-LINAC radiosurgery. Ten patients (5.58%) had no clinical follow-up. The median age was 74.0 years (range, 32-90 years). A total of 39 patients had secondary or atypical pain, and 130 had idiopathic TN. Initially, 28 patients received doses between 70 and 85 Gy, with the 30% isodose line (IDL) touching the brainstem. Then, using 90 Gy, 82 consecutive patients were treated with a 30% IDL and 59 patients with a 50% IDL tangential to the pons.
Of 169 patients, 134 (79.3%) experienced significant relief at a mean of 28.8 months (range, 5-142 months). Average time to relief was 1.92 months (range, immediate to 6 months). A total of 31 patients (19.0%) had recurrent pain at 13.5 months. Of 87 patients with idiopathic TN without prior procedures, 79 (90.8%) had initial relief. Among 28 patients treated with 70 Gy and 30% IDL, 18 patients (64.3%) had significant relief, and 10 (35.7%) had numbness. Of the patients with 90 Gy and 30% IDL at the brainstem, 59 (79.0%) had significant relief and 48.9% had numbness. Among 59 consecutive patients with similar dose but the 50% isodoseline at the brainstem, 49 patients (88.0%) had excellent/good relief. Numbness, averaging 2.49 on a subjective scale of 1 to 5, was experienced by 49.7% of the patients,
Increased radiation dose and volume of brainstem irradiation may improve clinical outcomes with the trade-off of trigeminal dysfunction. Further study of the implications of dose and target are needed to optimize outcomes and to minimize complications.
专用直线加速器放射外科(D-LINAC)已成为治疗三叉神经痛(TN)的重要手段。虽然伽玛刀的应用仍在不断确立,但使用 D-LINAC 的大系列研究很少。作者描述了他们的结果,比较了不同靶区和剂量方案的效果。
1995 年 8 月至 2008 年 1 月,179 例患者接受了 D-LINAC 放射外科治疗。10 例患者(5.58%)无临床随访。中位年龄为 74.0 岁(范围,32-90 岁)。共有 39 例患者有继发性或非典型性疼痛,130 例患者为特发性 TN。最初,28 例患者接受了 70 至 85 Gy 的剂量,30%等剂量线(IDL)触及脑干。然后,82 例连续患者采用 90 Gy 治疗,30% IDL 与桥脑相切,59 例采用 50% IDL 与桥脑相切。
169 例患者中,134 例(79.3%)在平均 28.8 个月(范围,5-142 个月)时出现明显缓解。缓解的平均时间为 1.92 个月(范围,即刻至 6 个月)。共有 31 例(19.0%)在 13.5 个月时出现复发性疼痛。在 87 例未经先前手术的特发性 TN 患者中,79 例(90.8%)有初始缓解。在 28 例接受 70 Gy 和 30% IDL 治疗的患者中,18 例(64.3%)有显著缓解,10 例(35.7%)有麻木感。在接受 90 Gy 和 30% IDL 治疗的脑干患者中,59 例(79.0%)有显著缓解,48.9%有麻木感。在 59 例连续接受类似剂量但脑干 50% IDL 治疗的患者中,49 例(88.0%)有极好/良好的缓解。49.7%的患者出现了平均 2.49(主观评分 1-5)的麻木感。
增加脑干的放射剂量和照射体积可能会改善临床结果,但需要权衡三叉神经功能障碍。需要进一步研究剂量和靶区的影响,以优化结果并最小化并发症。