Gallagher Peter, Wilson Nick, Edwards Richard, Cowie Rachael, Baker Michael G
Department of Public Health, University of Otago, Wellington, PO Box 7343 Wellington South 6021, New Zealand.
BMC Res Notes. 2011 Apr 7;4:111. doi: 10.1186/1756-0500-4-111.
An innovative approach to learning public health by using feature-length commercial movies was piloted in the fourth year of a medical degree. We aimed to explore how students responded to this approach and the relative effectiveness of two promotional strategies. Firstly we placed DVDs of 15 movies (with public health-related content) in the medical school library. Then alternating groups of students (total n = 82 students) were exposed to either a brief promotional intervention or a more intensive intervention involving a class presentation. The response rates were 99% at baseline and 85% at follow-up.
The level and strength of support for using movies in public health training increased after exposure to the public health module with significantly more students "strongly agreeing". Student behaviour, in terms of movies viewed or accessed from the library, also suggested student interest. While there were no statistically significant differences in median viewing or library access rates between the two intervention groups, the distribution of viewing patterns was shifted favourably. Those exposed to the more intensive intervention (class presentation) were significantly more likely to have reported watching at least one movie (97% vs. 81%; p = 0.033) or to having accessed at least one movie from the library (100% vs. 70%, p = 0.0001).
This pilot study found that the students had very positive attitudes towards viewing public health-related commercial movies. Movie access rates from the library were also favourable.
在医学学位课程的第四年,试点了一种通过使用故事片商业电影来学习公共卫生的创新方法。我们旨在探讨学生对这种方法的反应以及两种推广策略的相对有效性。首先,我们在医学院图书馆放置了15部电影(与公共卫生相关内容)的DVD。然后,将学生分成交替小组(总共82名学生),让他们分别接受简短的推广干预或更深入的干预,即课堂展示。基线时的反应率为99%,随访时为85%。
在接触公共卫生模块后,学生对在公共卫生培训中使用电影的支持程度和力度有所增加,有更多学生“强烈同意”。从图书馆观看或获取电影的学生行为也表明了他们的兴趣。虽然两个干预组之间在观看或从图书馆获取电影的中位数方面没有统计学上的显著差异,但观看模式的分布发生了有利的变化。接受更深入干预(课堂展示)的学生报告至少观看一部电影的可能性显著更高(97%对81%;p = 0.033),或者从图书馆获取至少一部电影的可能性显著更高(100%对70%,p = 0.0001)。
这项试点研究发现,学生对观看与公共卫生相关的商业电影持非常积极的态度。从图书馆获取电影的比例也很可观。