Department of Counseling and Clinical Psychology, Teachers College, Columbia University, New York, NY 10027, USA.
Cultur Divers Ethnic Minor Psychol. 2011 Jul;17(3):331-40. doi: 10.1037/a0024190.
Research on the experiences of faculty of color in predominantly White institutions (PWIs) suggests that they often experience the campus climate as invalidating, alienating, and hostile. Few studies, however, have actually focused on the classroom experiences of faculty of color when difficult racial dialogues occur. Using Consensually Qualitative Research, eight faculty of color were interviewed about their experiences in the classroom when racially tinged topics arose. Three major findings emerged. First, difficult racial dialogues were frequently instigated by the presence of racial microaggressions delivered toward students of color or the professor. Dialogues on race were made more difficult when the classrooms were diverse, when heated emotions arose, when there was a strong fear of self-disclosure, and when racial perspectives differed. Second, all faculty experienced an internal struggle between balancing their own values and beliefs with an attempt to remain objective. This conflict was often described as exhausting and energy-depleting. Third, faculty of color described both successful and unsuccessful strategies in facilitating difficult dialogues on race that arose in the course of their teaching. These findings have major implications for how PWIs can develop new programs, policies, and practices that will aid and support colleagues of color.
研究表明,少数族裔教员在以白人为主的院校(PWIs)中常常感到校园氛围具有否定性、疏远性和敌对性。然而,当出现困难的种族对话时,很少有研究真正关注少数族裔教员的课堂体验。本研究采用 Consensually Qualitative Research,对 8 位少数族裔教员进行了访谈,了解他们在课堂上遇到涉及种族问题时的经历。研究主要有以下三个发现:第一,种族微侵犯以及针对有色人种学生或教授的言论常常引发困难的种族对话。当课堂多元化、情绪激动、强烈害怕自我表露以及种族观点不同时,种族对话会变得更加困难。第二,所有教员都在努力保持客观的同时,在平衡自己的价值观和信念方面经历了内心的挣扎。这种冲突常常被描述为令人筋疲力尽和精力耗尽。第三,少数族裔教员描述了在教学过程中出现困难的种族对话时,成功和失败的促进策略。这些发现对于 PWI 如何制定新的项目、政策和实践,以帮助和支持有色人种同事具有重要意义。