Hayashi Masayoshi
Graduate School of Economics, The University of Tokyo, Hongo 7-3-1, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo 113-0033, Japan.
Int J Health Care Finance Econ. 2011 Dec;11(4):287-307. doi: 10.1007/s10754-011-9098-2. Epub 2011 Sep 14.
In countries where local governments are heavily involved in financing health care for the indigent, regional disparities in local revenues may adversely affect the access of the poor to medical care. It is thus important to examine how central governments provide funds for such local medical needs. In Japan, local governments finance all medical costs for the poor through their Public Assistance (PA) programs. Using the unique mechanism of the Japanese system of central grants, I construct a measure of "transfer deficit" which shows the portion of the PA expenditures that fails to be secured by the central grants. The distribution of such a measure provides important information to assess the regional equity in financing local programs. The results suggest a compromise on the regional equity in financing medical care for the indigent. Then, I explore the determinants of the deficit measure by performing a quantile regression analysis. Since no effects of potential determinants imply that the central grants well accommodate changes in local needs, finding such effects helps evaluate the performance of the transfer system. The results shows that, among others, the number of PA households and the factors related to mental illness of PA recipients have positive impacts that attenuate toward the top of the conditional quantile of the transfer deficit. I elaborate on plausible causes of such attenuating responses.
在地方政府大量参与为贫困人口提供医疗保健资金的国家,地方财政收入的地区差异可能会对穷人获得医疗服务产生不利影响。因此,研究中央政府如何为这类地方医疗需求提供资金非常重要。在日本,地方政府通过其公共援助(PA)计划为穷人支付所有医疗费用。利用日本中央拨款制度的独特机制,我构建了一个“转移赤字”指标,该指标显示了公共援助支出中未得到中央拨款保障的部分。这一指标的分布为评估地方项目融资中的地区公平性提供了重要信息。结果表明,在为贫困人口提供医疗保健的融资方面,地区公平性存在一定的妥协。然后,我通过进行分位数回归分析来探究赤字指标的决定因素。由于潜在决定因素没有影响意味着中央拨款能够很好地适应地方需求的变化,发现这些影响有助于评估转移支付系统的绩效。结果表明,除其他因素外,公共援助家庭数量和与公共援助受助者精神疾病相关的因素具有正向影响,且这种影响在转移赤字条件分位数的顶部会减弱。我详细阐述了这种减弱反应的合理原因。