Department of Medical Psychology and Psychotherapy, Erasmus University Medical Centre, Rotterdam, the Netherlands.
Med Educ. 2011 Nov;45(11):1090-100. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2923.2011.04060.x.
Arts subjects are often included in medical school curricula to facilitate the exploration of non-scientific elements of medicine, such as communication, social, political, emotional and spiritual issues. However, little research has reported on students' experience of arts teaching. Performing Medicine is a programme created by the Clod Ensemble theatre company in collaboration with Barts and The London School of Medicine and Dentistry, and the Department of Drama at Queen Mary University, London. Professional artists run a range of workshops exploring issues relating to health care and work to develop students' professional skills in self-presentation, observation, communication, self-care and their understanding of difference. This article presents an analysis of student-written material about Performing Medicine.
A dataset of written student materials (reflections and feedback), drawn from three academic years (2006-2009), was analysed using the qualitative methods of thematic analysis and word frequency analysis.
Five prevalent themes were identified: (i) Acting like a doctor; (ii) Developing broader awareness of others; (iii) The self in focus; (iv) The art of communication, and (v) A place for arts-based teaching within the medical curriculum. The corpus linguistic analysis confirmed and elaborated on the five themes found in the thematic analysis.
Students generally felt that arts teaching made a valuable contribution to the medical curriculum. Many felt the training would reduce 'performance anxiety' in situations such as examinations, presentations and new placements. Group work developed camaraderie and students enjoyed the opportunity to learn new skills through creative writing, theatre and movement sessions. Some sessions developed students' ability to engage with and relate to people from very different backgrounds than their own.
艺术学科通常被纳入医学院课程,以促进对医学中非科学元素的探索,如沟通、社会、政治、情感和精神问题。然而,很少有研究报告学生对艺术教学的体验。表演医学是由 Clod 剧团公司与巴茨和伦敦大学医学院以及伦敦玛丽女王大学戏剧系合作创建的一个项目。专业艺术家开展了一系列探讨与医疗保健相关问题的工作坊,并致力于培养学生在自我表达、观察、沟通、自我保健和理解差异方面的专业技能。本文对学生关于表演医学的书面材料进行了分析。
对三个学年(2006-2009 年)的书面学生材料(反思和反馈)数据集进行了分析,使用主题分析和词频分析的定性方法。
确定了五个普遍存在的主题:(i)像医生一样行动;(ii)更广泛地了解他人;(iii)关注自我;(iv)沟通的艺术;(v)艺术教学在医学课程中的地位。语料库语言学分析证实并详细说明了主题分析中发现的五个主题。
学生普遍认为艺术教学对医学课程做出了有价值的贡献。许多人认为培训将减少考试、演讲和新职位等情况下的“表现焦虑”。小组工作培养了同志情谊,学生们通过创意写作、戏剧和运动课程享受学习新技能的机会。一些课程培养了学生与自己背景非常不同的人接触和建立关系的能力。