Institute for Clinical Research and Health Policy Studies, Tufts Medical Center, Boston, Massachusetts 02111, USA.
Ann Intern Med. 2011 Nov 1;155(9):616-24. doi: 10.7326/0003-4819-155-9-201111010-00009.
Imaging under loading stress is hypothesized to improve the diagnostic value of magnetic resonancel imaging (MRI) for musculoskeletal conditions. This article reviews 57 studies about MRI under physiologic loading stress performed in an upright or sitting position or under axial loading by using a compression device. The most commonly imaged regions were the spine (33 studies) and knee (13 studies). Most studies had a cross-sectional (n = 37) or case-control (n = 13) design and reported on anatomical measurements rather than patient-relevant end points. Studies were generally small: The median (25th, 75th percentile) number of case patients was 26 (17, 45), and the median (25th, 75th percentile) number of control participants was 13 (12, 20 for case-control studies). Fifteen of 57 studies used at least 2 imaging tests and reported on diagnostic or patient-relevant outcomes but did not report meaningful information on the relative performance of the tests. In 10 studies that included information on adverse effects, 5% to 15% of participants reported new-onset or worsening pain and neuropathy during MRI under loading stress. Overall, evidence is insufficient to support the clinical utility of MRI under loading stress for musculoskeletal conditions.
在负重下进行影像学检查被假设可以提高磁共振成像(MRI)对肌肉骨骼疾病的诊断价值。本文综述了 57 项关于在直立或坐姿下或使用压缩装置进行轴向加载时进行的生理负荷下 MRI 的研究。最常成像的部位是脊柱(33 项研究)和膝关节(13 项研究)。大多数研究采用横断面(n = 37)或病例对照(n = 13)设计,报告解剖学测量值而不是与患者相关的终点。这些研究通常规模较小:中位数(25%,75%分位数)的病例患者数为 26(17,45),中位数(25%,75%分位数)的对照参与者数为 13(12,20 用于病例对照研究)。57 项研究中有 15 项至少使用了 2 种影像学检查,并报告了诊断或与患者相关的结果,但没有报告关于这些检查相对性能的有意义信息。在 10 项包含不良反应信息的研究中,5%至 15%的参与者在负重下进行 MRI 时报告出现新的或加重的疼痛和神经病变。总体而言,目前证据不足以支持在肌肉骨骼疾病中使用负重下的 MRI 的临床实用性。