School of Medicine, University of Sao Paulo, Sao Paulo, Brazil.
Arthritis Care Res (Hoboken). 2012 Mar;64(3):368-74. doi: 10.1002/acr.20690.
Previous studies indicate that flexible footwear, which mimics the biomechanics of walking barefoot, results in decreased knee loads in patients with knee osteoarthritis (OA) during walking. However, the effect of flexible footwear on other activities of daily living, such as descending stairs, remains unclear. Our objective was to evaluate the influence of inexpensive and minimalist footwear (Moleca) on knee adduction moment (KAM) during stair descent of elderly women with and without knee OA.
Thirty-four elderly women were equally divided into an OA group and a control group (CG). Stair descent was evaluated in barefoot condition, while wearing the Moleca, and while wearing heeled shoes. Kinematics and ground reaction forces were measured to calculate KAM by using inverse dynamics.
The OA group experienced a higher KAM during midstance under the barefoot condition (233.3%; P = 0.028), the Moleca (379.2%; P = 0.004), and heeled shoes (217.6%; P = 0.007). The OA group had a similar knee load during early, mid, and late stance with the Moleca compared with the barefoot condition. Heeled shoes increased the knee loads during the early-stance (versus barefoot [16.7%; P < 0.001] and versus the Moleca [15.5%; P < 0.001]), midstance (versus barefoot [8.6%; P = 0.014] and versus the Moleca [9.5%; P = 0.010]), and late-stance phase (versus barefoot [10.6%; P = 0.003] and versus the Moleca [9.2%; P < 0.001]). In the CG, the Moleca produced a knee load similar to the barefoot condition only during the early-stance phase.
Besides the general foot protection, the inexpensive and minimalist footwear contributes to decreasing knee loads in elderly women with OA during stair descent. The loads are similar to the barefoot condition and effectively decreased when compared with heeled shoes.
既往研究表明,模仿赤脚行走生物力学的弹性鞋可降低膝骨关节炎(OA)患者在行走时的膝关节负荷。然而,弹性鞋对其他日常生活活动(如下楼梯)的影响尚不清楚。我们的目的是评估廉价和极简主义鞋(Moleca)对膝内收力矩(KAM)的影响,以评估患有和不患有膝 OA 的老年女性在下楼梯时的情况。
34 名老年女性平均分为 OA 组和对照组(CG)。在赤脚、穿着 Moleca 和穿着高跟鞋的情况下评估下楼梯时的运动学和地面反作用力,以逆动力学计算 KAM。
OA 组在赤脚状态下的中期支撑(233.3%;P = 0.028)、Moleca(379.2%;P = 0.004)和高跟鞋(217.6%;P = 0.007)时的 KAM 更高。与赤脚状态相比,OA 组在中期支撑时穿着 Moleca 时的膝关节负荷相似。高跟鞋在早期支撑(与赤脚相比 [16.7%;P < 0.001] 和与 Moleca 相比 [15.5%;P < 0.001])、中期支撑(与赤脚相比 [8.6%;P = 0.014] 和与 Moleca 相比 [9.5%;P = 0.010])和晚期支撑阶段(与赤脚相比 [10.6%;P = 0.003] 和与 Moleca 相比 [9.2%;P < 0.001])时增加了膝关节负荷。在 CG 中,Moleca 仅在下楼初期支撑阶段产生与赤脚相似的膝关节负荷。
除了一般的足部保护外,廉价和极简主义的鞋子还可以降低 OA 老年女性下楼梯时的膝关节负荷。其效果与赤脚相似,与高跟鞋相比明显降低。