Kim Eun Young, Chung Myung Jin, Choe Yeon Hyeon, Lee Kyung Soo
Department of Radiology, Samsung Medical Center, Sungkyunkwan University School of Medicine, Seoul, Republic of Korea.
Acta Radiol. 2012 Feb 1;53(1):17-22. doi: 10.1258/ar.2011.110347. Epub 2011 Dec 2.
Recently developed digital tomosynthesis has shown improved detection of pulmonary lesions with a radiation dose comparable to conventional CR but with a much lower radiation dose than CT.
To compare the diagnostic performance of digital tomosynthesis (DT) with that of chest radiography (CR) for the detection of aortic arch calcification (AAC).
The study included 100 patients who underwent multidetector computed tomography (MDCT), DT, and CR (DT and CR were obtained within one week of CT examination). We evaluated and compared the diagnostic performances of DT and CR for the detection of AAC with MDCT as the reference standard. The extent (four grades 0-3) of AAC on DT and CR was also compared with CT calcium score. Inter-observer agreement was analyzed by using kappa statistics.
On DT, overall accuracy for AAC was superior to that of CR (94% and 71%, respectively, P < 0.01). Inter-observer agreement was good with DT and CR (kappa values = 0.74 and 0.62, respectively) for the presence of AAC, and good with DT and moderate with CR (kappa value = 0.64 and 0.53, respectively) for AAC grading. The overall correlation coefficient on AAC grading between DT and CT (calcium score) was superior to that between CR and CT (0.90 and 0.60, respectively).
DT is superior to CR for detection and extent evaluation of AAC.
最近开发的数字断层合成技术已显示出在检测肺部病变方面有所改进,其辐射剂量与传统CR相当,但远低于CT。
比较数字断层合成(DT)与胸部X线摄影(CR)对主动脉弓钙化(AAC)的诊断性能。
该研究纳入了100例接受多排螺旋CT(MDCT)、DT和CR检查的患者(DT和CR在CT检查后一周内进行)。我们以MDCT作为参考标准,评估并比较了DT和CR对AAC的诊断性能。还将DT和CR上AAC的程度(0 - 3级四个等级)与CT钙化评分进行了比较。采用kappa统计分析观察者间的一致性。
在DT上,AAC的总体准确率高于CR(分别为94%和71%,P < 0.01)。对于AAC的存在,DT和CR的观察者间一致性良好(kappa值分别为0.74和0.62),对于AAC分级,DT的一致性良好,CR的一致性中等(kappa值分别为0.64和0.53)。DT与CT(钙化评分)之间AAC分级的总体相关系数优于CR与CT之间的相关系数(分别为0.90和0.60)。
在AAC的检测和程度评估方面,DT优于CR。