Kaissi Amer
Department of Health Care Administration, Trinity University, One Trinity Place #58, San Antonio, TX 78212, USA.
Health Care Manag (Frederick). 2012 Jan-Mar;31(1):65-74. doi: 10.1097/HCM.0b013e318242d399.
Although it is true that health care has several distinguishing characteristics that set it apart, analysts both within and outside the industry point to several similarities with other fields and suggest opportunities for health care to learn from other industries. Applications from other industries have been described in the literature, but the transfer of learning at health care industry level has not been examined. This article investigates health care learning from other industries in the recent decade, focusing on aviation, high-reliability organizations, car manufacturing, telecommunication, car racing, entertainment, and retail; evidence suggests that most innovative practices originate with these fields. The diffusion of innovations from other industries appears to start with a few early adopter organizations (hospitals and health systems) and influential other organizations (The Joint Commission, Institute of Medicine, Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, or Institute for Healthcare Improvement) pushing for the innovations. Once the trend becomes accepted, consultants and copying behavior seem to contribute to its spread across the industry. An important question to explore is whether the applications in the early adopter organizations are different (in terms of their effectiveness) from those in the rest of the industry. Another intriguing issue is to examine whether other industries learn from health care organizations.
尽管医疗保健确实有几个使其与众不同的显著特征,但行业内外的分析师都指出它与其他领域存在一些相似之处,并提出医疗保健可向其他行业学习的机会。文献中已经描述了其他行业的应用情况,但尚未对医疗保健行业层面的学习转移进行研究。本文调查了近十年来医疗保健行业向其他行业的学习情况,重点关注航空、高可靠性组织、汽车制造、电信、赛车、娱乐和零售;有证据表明,大多数创新实践都源自这些领域。其他行业的创新传播似乎始于一些早期采用组织(医院和医疗系统)以及推动创新的有影响力的其他组织(联合委员会、医学研究所、医疗保健研究与质量局或医疗保健改进研究所)。一旦这种趋势被接受,顾问和模仿行为似乎有助于其在整个行业传播。一个值得探讨的重要问题是,早期采用组织中的应用在(有效性方面)是否与行业其他部分的应用有所不同。另一个有趣的问题是研究其他行业是否向医疗保健组织学习。