Department of Infectious Diseases, Hamedan University of Medical Sciences, Hamedan, Iran.
Int J Infect Dis. 2012 Apr;16(4):e247-51. doi: 10.1016/j.ijid.2011.12.003. Epub 2012 Jan 30.
Traditional regimens for the treatment of brucellosis are associated with significant relapse rates. The aim of this study was to compare the efficacy of ofloxacin plus rifampin (OFX-RIF) versus doxycycline plus streptomycin (DOX-STR) and doxycycline plus rifampin (DOX-RIF) regimens in the treatment of brucellosis.
Two hundred and nineteen patients with brucellosis were enrolled in a randomized clinical trial; 28 cases were withdrawn because they did not attend the follow-up. Out of 191 patients with brucellosis, 64 received OFX-RIF, 62 received DOX-RIF, and 65 patients received DOX-STR regimens. All patients were assessed during the period of therapy in the second, fourth, and sixth weeks by clinical course and were also followed up clinically and serologically for 6 months after the cessation of therapy.
The highest clinical response (95.4%) was observed in the DOX-STR group (p=0.009). The results of multivariate analysis indicate that treatment with DOX-STR had the least therapeutic failures among the three groups (p=0.033). Adverse reactions were seen in 16.8% of patients, but there was no significant difference among the three groups (p=0.613). The lowest relapse rate (4.6%) was observed in the DOX-STR group (p=0.109).
We conclude that the DOX-STR combination should remain the first-line regimen for the treatment of brucellosis in our region; we recommend DOX-RIF and OFX-RIF combinations as the second-line regimens.
传统的布鲁氏菌病治疗方案与较高的复发率相关。本研究旨在比较氧氟沙星联合利福平(OFX-RIF)、多西环素联合链霉素(DOX-STR)和多西环素联合利福平(DOX-RIF)方案治疗布鲁氏菌病的疗效。
219 例布鲁氏菌病患者参加了一项随机临床试验,28 例因失访而被排除。191 例布鲁氏菌病患者中,64 例接受 OFX-RIF 治疗,62 例接受 DOX-RIF 治疗,65 例接受 DOX-STR 治疗。所有患者在治疗的第 2、4 和 6 周通过临床病程进行评估,并在治疗停止后 6 个月进行临床和血清学随访。
DOX-STR 组的临床反应率最高(95.4%)(p=0.009)。多变量分析结果表明,DOX-STR 治疗组的治疗失败率最低(p=0.033)。三组不良反应发生率差异无统计学意义(p=0.613)。DOX-STR 组的复发率最低(4.6%)(p=0.109)。
我们得出结论,DOX-STR 联合治疗方案应继续作为本地区布鲁氏菌病的一线治疗方案;我们推荐 DOX-RIF 和 OFX-RIF 联合治疗方案作为二线治疗方案。