Jones Luke, Grammatopoulos George, Singer Gian
Department of Trauma and Orthopaedics, Wexham Park Hospital, Slough, UK.
Hip Int. 2012 Jan-Feb;22(1):28-34. doi: 10.5301/HIP.2012.9078.
Revision hip arthroplasty in cases with severe acetabular deficiency represents a technical challenge. The aim of this study was to determine: 1. The 9-year survival of the Burch Schneider anti-protrusio cage (BS-APC) in severe acetabular defects. 2. The migration of the cage and correlation of this with functional outcome. 3. The anticipated functional outcome users can expect in a district general hospital setting in the management of severe acetabular defects. A single-surgeon consecutive series of 30 complex acetabular reconstructions using the BS-APC was retrospectively reviewed. Clinical and radiological follow up at 5-9 years was obtained. Survival was established with revisions and further surgery as different end-points. A radiological analysis using ein bilt roentgen analyse (EBRA) was performed. At a mean follow-up of 85 months (range: 64-118) 26 patients (87%) were alive. Nine-year survival was 95% for revision of BS-APC as an end-point and 92% with any cause of further surgery as an end-point. The mean Oxford Hip Score was 34.5 and UCLA activity score was 4.4. All cases demonstrated evidence of significant migration, but no screws were found to be broken. There was no correlation between cup migration and Oxford hip score (p=0.07). Our non-specialist centre experience suggests the BS-APC should not be dismissed as a reconstruction option in the most severe acetabular defects.
在髋臼严重缺损的病例中进行髋关节翻修置换术是一项技术挑战。本研究的目的是确定:1. Burch Schneider防髋臼前突笼(BS - APC)在髋臼严重缺损中的9年生存率。2. 髋臼笼的移位情况及其与功能结果的相关性。3. 在地区综合医院环境中,使用BS - APC治疗髋臼严重缺损时患者预期的功能结果。回顾性分析了由单一外科医生连续进行的30例使用BS - APC的复杂髋臼重建病例。获得了5至9年的临床和影像学随访资料。以翻修手术和进一步手术作为不同终点来确定生存率。采用电子立体X线分析(EBRA)进行影像学分析。平均随访85个月(范围:64 - 118个月),26例患者(87%)存活。以BS - APC翻修为终点的9年生存率为95%,以任何原因导致的进一步手术为终点的9年生存率为92%。牛津髋关节评分平均为34.5分,加州大学洛杉矶分校(UCLA)活动评分为4.4分。所有病例均有明显移位的证据,但未发现螺钉断裂。髋臼杯移位与牛津髋关节评分之间无相关性(p = 0.07)。我们非专科中心的经验表明,在髋臼最严重缺损的情况下,BS - APC不应被排除作为一种重建选择。