Section of Psychological Medicine, Caledonia House, Royal Hospital for Sick Children, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, UK.
Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 2012 May;21(5):267-76. doi: 10.1007/s00787-012-0259-8. Epub 2012 Mar 3.
Children with a diagnosis of reactive attachment disorder (RAD) appear to show difficulties in social understanding. We aimed to compare the pragmatic language functioning of children with (RAD) and autism spectrum disorder (ASD). Assessments were made in three groups of children aged 5-8 years, with verbal IQ estimates in the normal range: 35 with a RAD diagnosis, 52 with an ASD diagnosis and 39 with typical development. The Children's Communication Checklist (CCC) was used to compare their pragmatic language skills, and ADI-R algorithms were used to compare autistic symptomatology, according to parent report. According to the CCC, the RAD group demonstrated significant problems in their use of context, rapport and social relationships with a degree of severity equivalent to children in the ASD comparison group. More than 60% of the group with RAD met ADI-R clinical criteria on the Use of Language and Other Social Communication Skills subscale, 46% on the Reciprocal Social Interaction subscale, and 20% had significant repetitive and stereotyped behaviours. Children with RAD appear to be at least as impaired as children with ASD in certain domains of social relatedness, particularly in their pragmatic language skills.
被诊断患有反应性依恋障碍(RAD)的儿童似乎在社会理解方面存在困难。我们旨在比较患有(RAD)和自闭症谱系障碍(ASD)的儿童的语用语言功能。评估在三组年龄为 5-8 岁、言语智商估计正常的儿童中进行:35 名患有 RAD 诊断,52 名患有 ASD 诊断,39 名具有典型发育。使用儿童沟通检查表(CCC)比较他们的语用语言技能,并根据家长报告使用 ADI-R 算法比较自闭症症状。根据 CCC,RAD 组在使用语境、融洽关系和社会关系方面表现出明显的问题,严重程度与 ASD 对照组的儿童相当。超过 60%的 RAD 组在使用语言和其他社会沟通技能子量表上符合 ADI-R 临床标准,46%在互惠社会互动子量表上符合标准,20%存在明显的重复和刻板行为。患有 RAD 的儿童在某些社交相关领域,特别是在他们的语用语言技能方面,似乎至少与患有 ASD 的儿童一样受损。