Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology, Leipzig, Germany.
J Child Lang. 2013 Mar;40(2):469-91. doi: 10.1017/S0305000912000050. Epub 2012 Mar 22.
Young children answer many questions every day. The extent to which they do this in an adult-like way - following Grice's Maxim of Quantity by providing the requested information, no more no less - has been studied very little. In an experiment, we found that two-, three- and four-year-old children are quite skilled at answering argument-focus questions and predicate-focus questions with intransitives in which their response requires only a single element. But predicate-focus questions for transitives - requiring both the predicate and the direct object - are difficult for children below four years of age. Even more difficult for children this young are sentence-focus questions such as "What's happening?", which give the child no anchor in given information around which to structure their answer. In addition, in a corpus study, we found that parents ask their children predicate-focus and sentence-focus questions very infrequently, thus giving children little experience with them.
幼儿每天都会回答很多问题。他们在多大程度上以成人的方式回答问题——遵循格莱斯的数量准则,提供请求的信息,不多不少——这方面的研究非常少。在一项实验中,我们发现,两岁、三岁和四岁的儿童在回答以不及物动词为焦点的争论焦点问题和谓语焦点问题时非常熟练,他们的回答只需要一个元素。但是对于及物动词的谓语焦点问题——需要谓语和直接宾语——对于四岁以下的儿童来说是困难的。对于这些年幼的孩子来说更困难的是句子焦点问题,例如“发生了什么事?”,这让孩子在给定的信息中没有一个可以用来构建答案的锚点。此外,在语料库研究中,我们发现父母很少向孩子提出谓语焦点和句子焦点问题,因此孩子很少有机会接触到这些问题。