Department of Philosophy, Center for Croatian Studies, University of Zagreb, Borongaj Campus, Croatia.
Dev World Bioeth. 2012 Dec;12(3):148-56. doi: 10.1111/j.1471-8847.2012.00330.x. Epub 2012 Jun 18.
Integrative bioethics is a brand of bioethics conceived and propagated by a group of Croatian philosophers and other scholars. This article discusses and shows that the approach encounters several serious difficulties. In criticizing certain standard views on bioethics and in presenting their own, the advocates of integrative bioethics fall into various conceptual confusions and inconsistencies. Although presented as a project that promises to deal with moral dilemmas created by modern science and technology, integrative bioethics does not contain the slightest normativity or action-guiding capacity. Portrayed as a scientific and interdisciplinary enterprise, integrative bioethics displays a large number of pseudoscientific features that throw into doubt its overall credibility.
整体生物伦理学是由一群克罗地亚哲学家和其他学者构思和传播的一种生命伦理学理念。本文讨论并表明,这种方法遇到了一些严重的困难。在批评某些标准的生命伦理学观点并提出自己的观点时,整体生物伦理学的倡导者陷入了各种概念上的混淆和不一致。尽管被呈现为一个有望解决现代科学技术所带来的道德困境的项目,但整体生物伦理学没有包含丝毫的规范性或行动指导能力。被描绘为一种科学的和跨学科的事业,整体生物伦理学显示出许多伪科学的特征,这使得其整体可信度受到质疑。