Department of Radiodiagnosis, ElMinia University Hospital, ElMinya High Road, ElMinya, Egypt.
Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol. 2013 Mar;270(3):1045-53. doi: 10.1007/s00405-012-2084-6. Epub 2012 Jun 27.
The purpose of this study was to determine the efficiency of Multidetector Computed Tomography (MDCT) versus MRI in detection and characterization of paragangliomas and differentiating them from other vascular mimicking conditions in the neck and skull base in comparison with histo-pathological results as a gold standard. A prospective study included 30 patients with vascular neck lesions. They were susceptible for MDCT and MRI for characterization of the nature of the lesions. Histo-pathological evaluation was performed in all lesions for confirmation. As a result of this study included 30 patients: 22 males and 8 females. Paragangliomas were the commonest detectable lesions; 12/30 patient had glomus tumor (1 glomus tympanicum, 2 glomus vegale, 4 glomus jugulo-tempanicum, and 5 glomus jugular), 6 carotid body tumor, 2 hemangiopericytoma, 3 vegal Schwanoma, 4 lymphadenopathy, 2 juvenile angiofibroma, and one neurofibroma. The sensitivity of MDCT was higher than MRI in differentiation of paragangliomas from other mimicking lesions, where MDCT sensitivity was 83.33 % and the NPV was 80 % while that of MRI was 77.7 % and the NPV 75 %, but both techniques have moderate agreement between them in differentiating paragangliomas from other mimicking vascular lesion. MDCT with its new utilities has near degree of accuracy in detection and localization of paragangliomas as the same that of MRI. Both techniques have moderate agreement between them in differentiating paragangliomas from other mimicking vascular lesions. So, it is better to use both of them as complementary techniques for accurate diagnosis and grading of paraganglioma.
这项研究的目的是确定多排螺旋计算机断层扫描(MDCT)与 MRI 在检测和表征头颈部副神经节瘤以及将其与其他血管模拟病变区分开来的效率,并与组织病理学结果作为金标准进行比较。一项前瞻性研究纳入了 30 例头颈部血管病变患者。他们均适合接受 MDCT 和 MRI 检查以明确病变性质。所有病变均行组织病理学评估以证实。该研究共纳入 30 例患者:22 例男性,8 例女性。副神经节瘤是最常见的可检测病变;30 例患者中,12 例为副神经节瘤(1 例鼓室球瘤、2 例迷走神经副神经节瘤、4 例颈静脉鼓室球瘤和 5 例颈静脉球瘤)、6 例颈动脉体瘤、2 例血管外皮细胞瘤、3 例迷走神经鞘瘤、4 例淋巴结病、2 例青少年血管纤维瘤和 1 例神经纤维瘤。MDCT 对副神经节瘤与其他模拟病变的鉴别诊断的敏感性高于 MRI,MDCT 的敏感性为 83.33%,NPV 为 80%,而 MRI 的敏感性为 77.7%,NPV 为 75%,但两种技术在鉴别副神经节瘤与其他模拟血管病变方面具有中度一致性。MDCT 具有新的应用价值,在检测和定位副神经节瘤方面具有与 MRI 相同的准确性。两种技术在鉴别副神经节瘤与其他模拟血管病变方面具有中度一致性。因此,最好将两者作为互补技术,以准确诊断和分级副神经节瘤。