CHU Clermont-Ferrand, Neurology Department, Clermont-Ferrand, France.
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 2012 Oct;83(10):1019-21. doi: 10.1136/jnnp-2012-302414. Epub 2012 Jun 29.
Although visual hallucinations in Parkinson's disease (PD) have been described in several major studies, little is known about olfactory hallucinations (OHs).
The authors performed a detailed analysis of OHs in a cohort of 87 Parkinsonian patients to estimate the prevalence of OHs and describe their phenomenology. They also evaluated smelling abilities in terms of detection and identification. Assessment of both, OHs and olfactory function, was also performed using a control group of 40 normal subjects.
Nine patients exhibited OHs compared with none of the controls, giving a prevalence of 10% for OHs in patients. OHs were described as rare, short-lasting, unpleasant odours which are not frightening since clearly identified by the patient as hallucinations. Parkinsonian patients with OHs exhibited olfactory impairment of detection and identification compared with controls, but there was no difference in their olfactory abilities from Parkinsonian patients without OHs.
In conclusion, OHs should be added to the list of non-motor PD symptoms that can occur early or late in the course of PD. The authors' study did not reveal any significant difference in terms of olfactory abilities between patients with or without OHs. However, olfactory impairment is well documented in Parkinsonian patients and cannot be totally ruled out as a risk factor for OHs. The authors recognise that complex mechanisms are probably involved in this phenomenon.
尽管在几项主要研究中已经描述了帕金森病(PD)中的视觉幻觉,但对嗅觉幻觉(OHs)知之甚少。
作者对 87 名帕金森病患者进行了 OHs 的详细分析,以估计 OHs 的患病率并描述其现象学。他们还根据检测和识别来评估嗅觉能力。使用 40 名正常受试者的对照组还评估了 OHs 和嗅觉功能。
与对照组相比,有 9 名患者出现 OHs,OHs 的患病率为 10%。OHs 被描述为罕见、短暂、不愉快的气味,由于患者明确将其识别为幻觉,因此并不令人恐惧。与对照组相比,患有 OHs 的帕金森病患者的检测和识别嗅觉受损,但与没有 OHs 的帕金森病患者相比,他们的嗅觉能力没有差异。
总之,OHs 应该添加到 PD 症状的非运动症状列表中,这些症状可以在 PD 的早期或晚期出现。作者的研究在有或没有 OHs 的患者之间的嗅觉能力方面没有发现任何显著差异。然而,帕金森病患者的嗅觉受损是有据可查的,不能完全排除其为 OHs 的危险因素。作者认识到,这种现象可能涉及复杂的机制。