Quack Johannes
University of Heidelberg, Germany.
Anthropol Med. 2012;19(3):277-90. doi: 10.1080/13648470.2012.692357. Epub 2012 Aug 8.
The paper discusses different positions by psychiatrists and anthropologists taken towards 'folk' mental health care and summarizes what has been said in favour of the folk sector. Further, examples indicating a changing relationship between the Indian state and the folk sector are outlined, including the impacts of the fire tragedy at the dargah of Erwadi in 2001. On this basis it is argued that a prevailing ignorance of the folk sector has provided it with some autonomy, while at the same time, recent attempts at collaboration tend to utilize folk practitioners rather than valuing their positive elements in their own right.
该论文讨论了精神病学家和人类学家对“民间”精神卫生保健所采取的不同立场,并总结了支持民间部门的观点。此外,还概述了印度国家与民间部门之间关系变化的例子,包括2001年埃尔瓦迪圣地火灾悲剧的影响。在此基础上,有人认为,对民间部门普遍的忽视赋予了它一定的自主性,而与此同时,最近的合作尝试往往是利用民间从业者,而不是重视他们自身的积极因素。