Ozar D T
Department of Philosophy, Loyola University Chicago, USA.
J Forensic Odontostomatol. 2012 Nov 30;30 Suppl 1:72-84.
While countries varies significantly in the financing of dental care, they are much more alike in the delivery of dentistry. Dental care is principally provided in dental offices and clinics that are independent business entities whose business leaders are most often the dentists themselves. However society expects from dentists a level of professionalism (i.e. habitually acting ethically, both in terms of competence and conduct) in contrast to the methods and motivations of the marketplace. This is why the single most important challenge of dental professional ethics continues to be giving proper priority to patients' well being and building ethically correct decision-making relationships with patients while, at the same time, trying to maintain a successful business operation. If we look into dentistry's future, the centrality of this aspect of professional ethics is not likely to change, although the ways in which dentists might violate this trust will probably multiple as funding mechanisms become increasingly complex. It is important that dentists reflect with fresh eyes on their ethical commitments. One challenge is the increased availability of oral health information to the public and the fact that so many people are uncritical of the accuracy of information in the media and on the web. A second is the increase in the amount of health care advertising in many societies. A third is the growth of aesthetic dentistry that differs from standard oral health care in important and ethically significant ways. The fourth is insurance that frequently complicates the explanation of a patient's treatment alternatives and often brings a third party into the treatment decision relationship. The ethical challenges of each of these factors will be considered and ultimately tying it to the central theme of dental professionalism.
虽然各国在牙科护理的资金筹集方面差异很大,但在牙科服务的提供方面却更为相似。牙科护理主要在牙科诊所和门诊部提供,这些都是独立的商业实体,其业务负责人通常就是牙医本人。然而,社会期望牙医具备一定水平的专业素养(即在能力和行为方面都习惯性地秉持道德规范),这与市场的运作方式和动机有所不同。这就是为什么牙科职业道德面临的最重要挑战仍然是适当优先考虑患者的福祉,并与患者建立符合道德规范的决策关系,同时努力维持成功的商业运营。展望牙科的未来,职业道德这一方面的核心地位不太可能改变,尽管随着资金机制日益复杂,牙医可能违背这种信任的方式可能会增多。牙医以全新的视角反思自己的道德承诺非常重要。一个挑战是公众获取口腔健康信息的渠道增多,而且很多人对媒体和网络上信息的准确性不加批判。第二个挑战是许多社会中医疗保健广告数量的增加。第三个挑战是美容牙科的发展,它在重要且具有道德意义的方面与标准口腔保健不同。第四个挑战是保险,它常常使向患者解释治疗方案变得复杂,并且常常使第三方介入治疗决策关系。将对这些因素各自带来的道德挑战进行考量,并最终将其与牙科专业素养的核心主题联系起来。