Research Unit for General Practice, Uni Health, Uni Research, Bergen, Norway.
Scand J Public Health. 2012 Dec;40(8):795-805. doi: 10.1177/1403494812465030.
To present background, principles, and procedures for a strategy for qualitative analysis called systematic text condensation and discuss this approach compared with related strategies.
Giorgi's psychological phenomenological analysis is the point of departure and inspiration for systematic text condensation. The basic elements of Giorgi's method and the elaboration of these in systematic text condensation are presented, followed by a detailed description of procedures for analysis according to systematic text condensation. Finally, similarities and differences compared with other frequently applied methods for qualitative analysis are identified, as the foundation of a discussion of strengths and limitations of systematic text condensation.
Systematic text condensation is a descriptive and explorative method for thematic cross-case analysis of different types of qualitative data, such as interview studies, observational studies, and analysis of written texts. The method represents a pragmatic approach, although inspired by phenomenological ideas, and various theoretical frameworks can be applied. The procedure consists of the following steps: 1) total impression - from chaos to themes; 2) identifying and sorting meaning units - from themes to codes; 3) condensation - from code to meaning; 4) synthesizing - from condensation to descriptions and concepts. Similarities and differences comparing systematic text condensation with other frequently applied qualitative methods regarding thematic analysis, theoretical methodological framework, analysis procedures, and taxonomy are discussed.
Systematic text condensation is a strategy for analysis developed from traditions shared by most of the methods for analysis of qualitative data. The method offers the novice researcher a process of intersubjectivity, reflexivity, and feasibility, while maintaining a responsible level of methodological rigour.
介绍一种名为系统文本浓缩的定性分析策略的背景、原则和程序,并将其与相关策略进行比较。
Giorgi 的心理现象学分析是系统文本浓缩的出发点和灵感来源。介绍了 Giorgi 方法的基本要素和在系统文本浓缩中的阐述,然后详细描述了根据系统文本浓缩进行分析的程序。最后,确定了与其他常用定性分析方法的相似点和不同点,为讨论系统文本浓缩的优缺点奠定了基础。
系统文本浓缩是一种描述性和探索性的方法,用于对不同类型的定性数据(如访谈研究、观察研究和书面文本分析)进行跨案例主题分析。该方法代表了一种实用主义方法,尽管受到现象学思想的启发,但可以应用各种理论框架。该程序包括以下步骤:1)总体印象 - 从混乱到主题;2)识别和分类意义单位 - 从主题到代码;3)浓缩 - 从代码到意义;4)综合 - 从浓缩到描述和概念。讨论了系统文本浓缩与其他常用的定性分析方法在主题分析、理论方法论框架、分析程序和分类方面的异同。
系统文本浓缩是一种从大多数定性数据分析方法所共有的传统发展而来的分析策略。该方法为新手研究人员提供了一种主体间性、反思性和可行性的过程,同时保持了负责任的方法论严谨性。