Hegney Desley, Eley Robert, Francis Karen
School of Nursing and Midwifery, Curtin University, Curtin Health Innovation Research Institute, Australia; Centre for Nursing Research, Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital, Perth, Australia.
Nurse Educ Today. 2013 Oct;33(10):1148-52. doi: 10.1016/j.nedt.2012.11.023. Epub 2012 Dec 27.
In Australia, unlike other countries, programmes which lead to registration as a registered or enrolled nurse (called "entry to practice" programmes) are carried out solely in the tertiary sector. In Australian nursing and the wider community, there continues to be a debate over the place of preparation and the "work readiness" of graduates.
Despite several opinion papers on the preparation of registered nurses, there is a dearth of published research on the perceptions of the clinical nursing workforce on the suitability of the current preparation for practice models.
Data were collected from approximately 3000 nurses in Queensland, Australia in 2007 and 2010. The aim of these studies was to ascertain issues around nursing work. This paper reports on qualitative data that were collected as part of that larger survey. Specifically this paper provides the thematic analysis of one open-ended question: "what are the five key issues and strategies that you see could improve nursing and nursing work?" as it was apparent when we undertook thematic analysis of this question that there was a major theme around the preparation of nurses for the nursing workforce. We therefore carried out a more detailed thematic analysis around this major theme.
The major sub-themes that we identified from comments on the preparation of the nursing workforce were: perceptions of lack of clinical exposure and the need to increase the amount of clinical hours; the design of the curriculum, the place of preparation (solely within industry or a great focus on industry), financial consideration (students to be paid for their work); and in 2007 only, the need for students to have better time management.
The findings suggest that a majority of respondents believed there should be changes to the entry to practice preparation for nurses. The major focus of these comments was the perception of insufficient clinical experience and inappropriate curriculum content. Thus, graduates are not "work ready".
The attitude of clinical nurses, who work closely with student nurses, influences the workplace experience of student nurses. It is apparent from the statements of respondents in this study, that there is a need for stronger industry/academic partnerships, particularly around the design and implementation of the entry-to-practice curriculum.
在澳大利亚,与其他国家不同,通向注册护士或登记护士注册(即“从业入门”项目)的课程仅在高等教育部门开展。在澳大利亚护理界及更广泛的社会中,关于培养地点以及毕业生的“工作准备情况”的争论仍在继续。
尽管有几篇关于注册护士培养的意见书,但关于临床护理人员对当前实践模式培养适宜性看法的已发表研究却很匮乏。
2007年和2010年从澳大利亚昆士兰州约3000名护士中收集数据。这些研究的目的是确定围绕护理工作的问题。本文报告作为该大型调查一部分收集的定性数据。具体而言,本文提供了对一个开放式问题的主题分析:“你认为可改善护理及护理工作的五个关键问题和策略是什么?”因为当我们对这个问题进行主题分析时,很明显围绕护士进入护理队伍的培养存在一个主要主题。因此,我们围绕这个主要主题进行了更详细的主题分析。
我们从对护理人员培养的评论中确定的主要子主题有:感觉临床接触不足以及增加临床时长的必要性;课程设计、培养地点(仅在行业内或高度关注行业)、财务考量(应为学生工作支付报酬);以及仅在2007年提到的学生需要更好地管理时间。
研究结果表明,大多数受访者认为护士从业入门培养应该做出改变。这些评论的主要焦点是感觉临床经验不足和课程内容不合适。因此,毕业生没有“做好工作准备”。
与实习护士密切合作的临床护士的态度会影响实习护士的工作场所体验。从本研究受访者的陈述中可以明显看出,需要加强行业/学术伙伴关系,特别是在从业入门课程的设计和实施方面。