Inagaki Ataru, Mizuno Masafumi, Fujiwara Shuichiro, Enokido Fusako, Tsujino Naohisa, Nemoto Yasushi, Nozaki Shoko, Kojima Takuya
Center for Clinical Psychopharmacology, Institute of Neuropsychiatry.
Seishin Shinkeigaku Zasshi. 2012;114(12):1374-84.
The shortage of psychiatrists has recently become a public concern; however, the reason for this shortage has not been clearly discussed or explained on the basis of real data. We assumed that it is not only due to the lack of the absolute number of psychiatrists, but also due to an imbalance in their distribution in geographical working areas and settings.
To evaluate the change in distribution of Japanese psychiatrists.
We analyzed the change in the geographical working area and setting of each psychiatrist from September 2006 to March 2009 using data obtained from psychiatrists who applied for the Board Certification Examination of the Japanese Psychiatric Association. Our data included 6,881 psychiatrists.
With regard to the geographical working area, the number of psychiatrists in ordinance-designated cities (urban areas) increased by 2.2%, whereas that in other areas decreased by 3.0%. On examination of work settings, we noted a 16.0% decrease in the number of psychiatric departments in general hospitals and a 20.0% increase in the number of psychiatric clinics. Surprisingly, more than 10% of middle-aged psychiatrists (10.3% of 36 45-year-olds and 12.2% of 46-55-year olds) who worked in general hospitals moved to clinics.
The present study revealed that, although psychiatrists did not tend to move from rural to urban areas, they showed a tendency to move from general hospitals to psychiatric clinics.
精神科医生短缺问题近来已成为公众关注的焦点;然而,基于实际数据,这一短缺现象的原因尚未得到清晰的探讨或解释。我们认为,其原因不仅在于精神科医生绝对数量的不足,还在于其在地理工作区域和工作环境中的分布不均衡。
评估日本精神科医生分布的变化情况。
我们利用从申请日本精神科协会委员会认证考试的精神科医生处获得的数据,分析了2006年9月至2009年3月期间每位精神科医生的地理工作区域和工作环境的变化。我们的数据涵盖了6881名精神科医生。
在地理工作区域方面,政令指定城市(市区)的精神科医生数量增加了2.2%,而其他地区则减少了3.0%。在对工作环境的调查中,我们注意到综合医院精神科的数量减少了16.0%,而精神科诊所的数量增加了20.0%。令人惊讶的是,在综合医院工作的中年精神科医生中有超过10%(45岁的占10.3%,46 - 55岁的占12.2%)转到了诊所工作。
本研究表明,尽管精神科医生并非倾向于从农村地区流向城市地区,但他们表现出从综合医院流向精神科诊所的趋势。