Department of Radiation Oncology, Institut Curie, Paris, France.
Br J Radiol. 2013 May;86(1025):20120643. doi: 10.1259/bjr.20120643. Epub 2013 Feb 25.
To assess the visualisation of the left anterior descending (LAD) coronary artery on CT images used for breast radiation treatment planning.
Delineation of the LAD artery was achieved for 25 breast patients by 1 radiologist and 1 radiation oncologist independently on two sets of images for each patient: one pre-operative CT scan using intravenous (IV) contrast media to determine the primary gross tumour volume (GTV) and one post-operative CT scan used for treatment planning. A Student's paired t-test was used to compare the number of CT slices in which the LAD was visible for each patient in the two series. Interpolations and extrapolations of the LAD volume were performed for the left-sided cases using a published heart atlas in order to report doses to the LAD structure.
There was a non-significant difference between the results with and without IV contrast media (p=0.34 for the radiologist; p=0.90 for the radiation oncologist). The visible LAD artery corresponded to a 30% portion (range 12-47%) of the interpolated structure. The maximum dose to the left artery varied widely, from 2.7 to 41.7 Gy, in the group of patients with left breast tumours. The largest values (>25 Gy) corresponded to those patients in whom the LAD artery distal extremity lay inside the breast fields.
With the current planning CT protocol, only one-third of the LAD artery could be objectively visualised. Contrast-enhanced imaging used for GTV delineation before the breast surgery did not improve the visualisation of the artery.
This study has revealed the lack of consistency that may be encountered when contouring heart vessels, thereby questioning the reliability of dose reporting.
评估用于乳腺癌放射治疗计划的 CT 图像中左前降支(LAD)冠状动脉的可视化效果。
一位放射科医生和一位放射肿瘤学家分别对 25 名乳腺癌患者的两组图像进行了 LAD 动脉的勾画:一组是术前静脉(IV)对比增强 CT 扫描,用于确定主要大体肿瘤体积(GTV);另一组是术后 CT 扫描,用于治疗计划。采用学生配对 t 检验比较了两组患者中 LAD 在每例患者可见的 CT 切片数。使用发表的心解剖图谱对左侧病例进行 LAD 体积的内插和外推,以报告 LAD 结构的剂量。
有和无 IV 对比剂的结果之间无统计学差异(放射科医生 p=0.34;放射肿瘤学家 p=0.90)。可见的 LAD 动脉对应于插值结构的 30%部分(范围 12-47%)。左冠状动脉的最大剂量变化很大,从 2.7 到 41.7Gy,在左侧乳腺癌患者组中。最大值(>25Gy)对应于 LAD 动脉远端位于乳房野内的患者。
根据当前的计划 CT 方案,只有三分之一的 LAD 动脉可以客观地可视化。在乳房手术前用于 GTV 勾画的增强成像并不能改善动脉的可视化效果。
本研究揭示了在勾画心脏血管时可能遇到的缺乏一致性,从而质疑剂量报告的可靠性。