Department of Sociology, 2112 Art-Sociology Building, University of Maryland, College Park, MD 20742, United States.
Soc Sci Res. 2013 May;42(3):836-51. doi: 10.1016/j.ssresearch.2012.12.017. Epub 2013 Jan 7.
This paper examines three outcomes characterizing different aspects of post 9/11 veterans' economic reintegration to civilian life: unemployment, earnings and college enrollment, using Current Population Survey data from 2005 to 2011. Analyses include interactions of veteran status with sex, race/ethnicity and educational attainment to evaluate whether diverse veterans experience diverse consequences of service. In brief, I find that the basic unemployment differences between veterans and non-veterans often reported in the media understate the effect of military service on unemployment for men, since veterans have other characteristics that are associated with higher employment rates. Female veterans appear to suffer a steeper employment penalty than male veterans, but black veterans appear to suffer less of a penalty than white veterans. But on two other measures, earnings and college enrollment, veterans appear to be doing better than their civilian peers. Veterans with a high school education or less outearn their civilian peers, but veterans with at least some college education appear to lose some or all of the veteran earnings advantage compared to veterans with a high school degree, suggesting the greatest wage returns to military service accrue among the least educated. Veterans with at least a high school education are more likely to be enrolled in college than their civilian peers. Treating veterans as a monolithic block obscures differences in the consequences of military service across diverse groups.
本文使用 2005 年至 2011 年的“当前人口调查”数据,考察了后 9/11 时代退伍军人重新融入平民生活的三个方面的不同结果:失业、收入和大学入学率。分析包括退伍军人身份与性别、种族/族裔和教育程度的相互作用,以评估不同的退伍军人是否经历了不同的服务后果。简而言之,我发现媒体经常报道的退伍军人和非退伍军人之间的基本失业差异低估了兵役对男性失业的影响,因为退伍军人还有其他与更高就业率相关的特征。女性退伍军人的就业惩罚似乎比男性退伍军人更严重,但黑人退伍军人的惩罚似乎比白人退伍军人少。但在另外两个衡量标准,收入和大学入学率上,退伍军人似乎比他们的平民同龄人表现更好。高中或以下学历的退伍军人收入高于同龄人,但至少有一些大学学历的退伍军人与高中毕业生相比,似乎失去了部分或全部退伍军人收入优势,这表明兵役的最大工资回报来自受教育程度最低的人。至少受过高中教育的退伍军人比同龄人更有可能上大学。将退伍军人视为一个整体掩盖了不同群体在兵役后果方面的差异。