Department of Pathology, Copenhagen University Hospital, Hvidovre, Denmark.
PLoS One. 2013;8(3):e59765. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0059765. Epub 2013 Mar 22.
New commercially available Human Papillomavirus (HPV) assays need to be evaluated in a variety of cervical screening settings. Cobas HPV Test (cobas) is a real-time PCR-based assay allowing for separate detection of HPV genotypes 16 and 18 and a bulk of 12 other high-risk genotypes. The aim of the present study, Horizon, was to assess the prevalence of high-risk HPV infections in an area with a high background risk of cervical cancer, where women aged 23-65 years are targeted for cervical screening. We collected 6,258 consecutive cervical samples from the largest cervical screening laboratory in Denmark serving the whole of Copenhagen. All samples were stored in SurePath media. In total, 5,072 samples were tested with cobas, Hybrid Capture 2 High Risk HPV DNA test (HC2) and liquid-based cytology. Of these, 27% tested positive on cobas. This proportion decreased by age, being 43% in women aged 23-29 years and 10% in women aged 60-65 years. HC2 assay was positive in 20% of samples, and cytology was abnormal (≥ atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance) for 7% samples. When only samples without recent abnormalities were taken into account, 24% tested positive on cobas, 19% on HC2, and 5% had abnormal cytology. The proportion of positive cobas samples was higher than in the ATHENA trial. The age-standardized cobas positivity vs. cytology abnormality was 3.9 in our study and 1.7 in ATHENA. If in Copenhagen the presently used cytology would be replaced by cobas in women above age 30 years, an extra 11% of women would based on historical data be expected to have a positive cobas test without an underlying cervical intraepithelial lesion grade 3 or worse. Countries with a high prevalence of HPV infections should therefore proceed to primary HPV-based cervical screening with caution.
新的商业化人乳头瘤病毒(HPV)检测方法需要在各种宫颈筛查环境中进行评估。Cobas HPV 检测(cobas)是一种基于实时 PCR 的检测方法,能够单独检测 HPV 基因型 16 和 18 以及其他 12 种高危型 HPV 基因型。本研究(Horizon)的目的是评估在宫颈癌高发背景地区高危 HPV 感染的流行率,该地区的目标人群为 23-65 岁的女性进行宫颈筛查。我们从丹麦最大的宫颈筛查实验室收集了 6258 例连续的宫颈样本,该实验室服务于哥本哈根全市。所有样本均保存在 SurePath 培养基中。共有 5072 例样本用 cobas、杂交捕获 2 型高危型 HPV DNA 检测(HC2)和液基细胞学进行了检测。其中,27%的样本在 cobas 上呈阳性。这一比例随年龄下降,23-29 岁女性中为 43%,60-65 岁女性中为 10%。HC2 检测阳性率为 20%,细胞学异常(≥非典型鳞状细胞意义不明确)率为 7%。当仅考虑最近无异常的样本时,24%的样本在 cobas 上呈阳性,19%的样本在 HC2 上呈阳性,5%的样本细胞学异常。cobas 阳性样本的比例高于 ATHENA 试验。在本研究中,年龄标准化 cobas 阳性与细胞学异常的比值为 3.9,ATHENA 试验中为 1.7。如果在哥本哈根,目前使用的细胞学检查在 30 岁以上的女性中被 cobas 取代,根据历史数据,预计将有额外 11%的女性的 cobas 检测结果呈阳性,而无宫颈上皮内瘤变 3 级或更高级别病变。因此,HPV 感染率较高的国家应谨慎推进基于 HPV 的初级宫颈筛查。