Division of Pediatric Surgery, Ann and Robert H Lurie Children's Hospital of Chicago, Chicago, IL 60611, USA.
J Pediatr Surg. 2013 Jun;48(6):1232-8. doi: 10.1016/j.jpedsurg.2013.03.015.
We sought to create and validate a high fidelity, anatomically correct real tissue simulation model for thoracoscopic esophageal atresia/tracheoesophageal fistula (EA/TEF) repair.
A scale reproduction of a neonatal rib cage was created. Surgically modified (EA/TEF) fetal bovine tissue completed the simulator. Nine pediatric surgery fellows and two attending pediatric surgeons (n=11) performed the simulated thoracoscopic EA/TEF repair. Participants completed a self-report rating scale, ranging from 1 (Don't know) to 5 (Highly realistic). Construct validity relevant to test content was evaluated by examining the ratings using the many-Facet Rasch model.
Analyses indicated no differences when comparing faculty (Observed Average (OA)=4.5/5.0) to fellow (OA=3.3) ratings, p=.71. In descending order, observed averages of the domains were 4.7 (Relevance), 4.5 (Physical attributes), 4.5 (Realism of materials), 4.4 (Ability to perform task), and 4.2 (Value). The observed Global opinion rating indicated the simulator can be considered for teaching thoracoscopic EA/TEF repair but could be improved slightly.
Fellow and faculty ratings indicated the simulator was valuable as a learning tool with minor modifications. Comments were consistent with high physical attribute ratings.
我们旨在创建并验证一种高保真、解剖结构正确的真实组织模拟模型,用于胸腔镜食管闭锁/气管食管瘘(EA/TEF)修复。
创建了一个新生儿肋骨的比例复制品。手术修改的(EA/TEF)胎牛组织完成了模拟器。9 名儿科外科研究员和 2 名主治儿科外科医生(n=11)进行了模拟胸腔镜 EA/TEF 修复。参与者完成了自我报告评分量表,范围从 1(不知道)到 5(非常真实)。使用多方面 Rasch 模型评估与测试内容相关的构建有效性,通过检查评分来评估。
分析表明,教师(观察平均值(OA)=4.5/5.0)与研究员(OA)=3.3 的评分没有差异,p=.71。按降序排列,域的观察平均值分别为 4.7(相关性)、4.5(物理属性)、4.5(材料的逼真度)、4.4(执行任务的能力)和 4.2(价值)。观察到的总体意见评分表明,该模拟器可用于胸腔镜 EA/TEF 修复教学,但可稍作改进。
研究员和教师的评分表明,该模拟器作为一种学习工具具有价值,只需进行一些小的修改。评论与高物理属性评分一致。