Sobani Zain-ul-abedeen, Mohyuddin Muhammad Masaud, Farooq Fahd, Qaiser Kanza Noor, Gani Faiz, Bham Nida Shahab, Raheem Ahmed, Mehraj Vikram, Saeed Syed Abdul, Sharif Hasanat, Sheerani Mughis, Zuberi Rukhsana Wamiq, Beg Mohamamd Asim
Research Associate, Aga Khan University, Karachi Pakistan. 8Universite de la Mediterranee, Faculte de Medecine, 27 Bid. Jean Moulin, Marseille, France.
J Pak Med Assoc. 2013 Jul;63(7):935-9.
To determine levels of professionalism in undergraduate medical students at a private medical college and assess how changes emerge during their training.
The study was conducted at Aga Khan University, a tertiary care teaching hospital, during November and December 2011. Freshmen, Year 3 and Year 5 students were requested to fill out a questionnaire. It was designed to assess the participants' levels of professionalism and how they perceived the professional environment around them by incorporating previously described scales. The questionnaire was re-validated on a random sample of practising clinicians at the same hospital. SPSS 17 was used for statistical analysis.
The study sample comprised 204 participants. The mean score for level of individual professionalism was 7.72+/-3.43. Only 13 (6.4%) students had a score one standard deviation above the faculty mean. About 24 (11.8%) were one standard deviation and 35 (17.2%) were 2 standard deviations below the faculty mean. The remaining 130 (63.7%) were >2 standard deviations below the faculty mean. Considering the level of education, the mean score for level of professionalism was 8.00+/-3.39 for freshmen, 6.85+/-3.41 for year 3 students, and 8.40+/-3.34 for year 5 students.
The currently employed teaching practices inculcating the values of professionalism in medical students are serving as a buffer to maintain the pre-training levels of professionalism from declining.
确定一所私立医学院校本科医学生的专业素养水平,并评估其在培训过程中专业素养水平的变化情况。
本研究于2011年11月至12月在阿迦汗大学(一家三级护理教学医院)开展。要求大一、大三和大五的学生填写一份问卷。该问卷旨在通过纳入先前描述的量表来评估参与者的专业素养水平以及他们对周围专业环境的认知。该问卷在同一家医院的执业临床医生随机样本中进行了重新验证。使用SPSS 17进行统计分析。
研究样本包括204名参与者。个人专业素养水平的平均得分为7.72±3.43。只有13名(6.4%)学生的得分高于教师平均得分一个标准差。约24名(11.8%)学生低于教师平均得分一个标准差,35名(17.2%)学生低于教师平均得分两个标准差。其余130名(63.7%)学生低于教师平均得分两个标准差以上。考虑到教育水平,大一学生专业素养水平的平均得分为8.00±3.39,大三学生为6.85±3.41,大五学生为8.40±3.34。
目前用于向医学生灌输专业素养价值观的教学实践起到了缓冲作用,防止他们培训前的专业素养水平下降。