Aciduman Ahmet, Arda Berna, Aşkit Cağatay, Belen Deniz, Tuzcu Kemal
Department of History of Medicine and Ethics, Faculty of Medicine, Ankara University, Ankara, Turkey.
Department of History of Medicine and Ethics, Faculty of Medicine, Ankara University, Ankara, Turkey.
World Neurosurg. 2014 Dec;82(6):e791-6. doi: 10.1016/j.wneu.2013.07.077. Epub 2013 Aug 17.
To present the text on hydrocephalus from Haly Abbas's book Kitāb al-Malikī / Liber Regius (The Royal Book), which was accepted as a classical textbook in the Eastern and Western worlds for a long time.
The Arabic (Süleymaniye Manuscript Library, Murad Molla Collection, Nr: 1482 and Būlāḳ, 1294 /1877) and the Latin (Venice, 1492) versions of the related chapter was translated and compared to create an English text. Additionally, relevant literature was reviewed in detail.
The text on hydrocephalus in Haly Abbas's The Royal Book virtually resembles Paul of Aegina's work. For hydrocephalic cases where the fluid collects between skin and pericranium, and pericranium and bone, Haly Abbas had made little change in surgical intervention; for the third type, skin incision, he preferred a T-type incision instead of an H-type. Like Paul of Aegina, Haly Abbas also did not advise any surgical intervention for the cases of hydrocephalus, where fluid accumulation is between bone and the dura mater.
Haly Abbas's approach to hydrocephalus was as brave as that of his predecessors Antyllus, Oribasius, and Paulus, although the cases they dealt with were almost all cephalic hematomas. Although his chapter on the treatment of water accumulation in the head contains surgical interventions in extracranial hydrocephalic conditions, his account on hydrocephalus is extremely precise and gives adequate detail as in other chapters in his book.
呈现哈利·阿巴斯(Haly Abbas)所著《皇家之书》(Kitāb al-Malikī / Liber Regius)中关于脑积水的内容,该书在很长一段时间内被东西方世界奉为经典教科书。
对相关章节的阿拉伯语版本(苏莱曼尼耶手稿图书馆,穆拉德·莫拉藏书,编号:1482以及布拉克,1294/1877)和拉丁语版本(威尼斯,1492)进行翻译并比较,以创建英文文本。此外,还详细查阅了相关文献。
哈利·阿巴斯《皇家之书》中关于脑积水的内容与埃伊纳岛的保罗(Paul of Aegina)的著作极为相似。对于脑脊液积聚在皮肤与颅骨膜之间以及颅骨膜与颅骨之间的脑积水病例,哈利·阿巴斯在手术干预方面变化不大;对于第三种类型,即皮肤切口,他更倾向于采用T型切口而非H型切口。与埃伊纳岛的保罗一样,哈利·阿巴斯对于脑脊液积聚在颅骨与硬脑膜之间的脑积水病例也不建议进行任何手术干预。
哈利·阿巴斯对脑积水的处理方法与他的前辈安提卢斯(Antyllus)、奥里巴西乌斯(Oribasius)和保卢斯(Paulus)一样大胆,尽管他们处理的病例几乎都是头部血肿。虽然他关于头部积水治疗的章节包含了颅外脑积水情况的手术干预,但他对脑积水的描述极其精确,并且像他书中的其他章节一样给出了足够的细节。