Niederhauser Blake D, Liaw Kevin, McDonald Robert J, Thomas Kristen B, Hudson Kathleen T, Kallmes David F
Department of Radiology, Mayo Clinic, 200 1st St. SW, Rochester, MN, 55905, USA,
J Digit Imaging. 2014 Feb;27(1):26-32. doi: 10.1007/s10278-013-9638-z.
The purpose of this study was to investigate radiologist and trainee-preferred sources for solving imaging questions. The institutional review board determined this study to be exempt from informed consent requirements. Web-based surveys were distributed to radiology staff and trainees at 16 academic institutions. Surveys queried ownership and use of tablet computers and habits of utilization of various electronic and hardcopy resources for general reference. For investigating specific cases, respondents identified a single primary resource. Comparisons were performed using Fisher's exact test. For staff, use of Google and online journals was nearly universal for general imaging questions (93 [103/111] and 94 % [104/111], respectively). For trainees, Google and resident-generated study materials were commonly utilized for such questions (82 [111/135] and 74 % [100/135], respectively). For specific imaging questions, online journals and PubMed were rarely chosen as a primary resource; the most common primary resources were STATdx for trainees and Google for staff (44 [55/126] and 52 % [51/99], respectively). Use of hard copy journals was nearly absent among trainees. Sixty percent of trainees (78/130) own a tablet computer versus 41 % of staff (46/111; p = 0.005), and 71 % (55/78) of those trainees reported at least weekly use of radiology-specific tablet applications, compared to 48 % (22/46) of staff (p < 0.001). Staff radiologists rely heavily on Google for both general and specific imaging queries, while residents utilize customized, radiology-focused products and apps. Interestingly, residents note continued use of hard copy books but have replaced hard copy journals with online resources.
本研究的目的是调查放射科医生和实习医生在解决影像问题时更倾向的信息来源。机构审查委员会认定本研究无需获得知情同意。通过网络调查向16所学术机构的放射科工作人员和实习医生发放问卷。问卷询问了平板电脑的拥有和使用情况以及使用各种电子和纸质资源进行一般参考的习惯。对于具体病例的调查,受访者需确定单一的主要信息来源。采用Fisher精确检验进行比较。对于工作人员,在一般影像问题上,使用谷歌和在线期刊的情况几乎很普遍(分别为93%[103/111]和94%[104/111])。对于实习医生,在这类问题上常用谷歌和住院医生制作的学习资料(分别为82%[111/135]和74%[100/135])。对于具体的影像问题,在线期刊和PubMed很少被选为主要信息来源;最常用的主要信息来源,实习医生是STATdx,工作人员是谷歌(分别为44%[55/126]和52%[51/99])。实习医生几乎不使用纸质期刊。60%的实习医生(78/130)拥有平板电脑,而工作人员的这一比例为41%(46/111;p = 0.005),并且71%(55/78)的实习医生报告至少每周使用放射科专用平板电脑应用程序,而工作人员的这一比例为48%(22/46;p < 0.001)。放射科工作人员在一般和具体影像查询方面都严重依赖谷歌,而住院医生则使用定制的、专注于放射学的产品和应用程序。有趣的是,住院医生指出他们仍在继续使用纸质书籍,但已用在线资源取代了纸质期刊。