Mohammad Alshafi, Branicki Frank, Abu-Zidan Fikri M
Trauma Group, Department of Surgery, College of Medicine and Health Sciences, United Arab Emirates University, PO Box 17666, Al Ain, United Arab Emirates.
World J Surg. 2014 Feb;38(2):322-9. doi: 10.1007/s00268-013-2294-0.
We aimed to systematically review the literature on the educational impact of Advanced Trauma Life Support (ATLS) courses and their effects on death rates of multiple trauma patients.
All Medline, Pubmed, and the Cochrane Library English articles on the educational impact of ATLS courses and their effects on trauma mortality for the period 1966-2012 were studied. All original articles written in English were included. Surveys, reviews, editorials/letters, and other trauma courses or models different from the ATLS course were excluded. Articles were critically evaluated regarding study research design, statistical analysis, outcome, and quality and level of evidence.
A total of 384 articles were found in the search. Of these, 104 relevant articles were read; 23 met the selection criteria and were critically analyzed. Ten original articles reported studies on the impact of ATLS on cognitive and clinical skills, six articles addressed the attrition of skills gained through ATLS training, and seven articles addressed the effects of ATLS on trauma mortality. There is level I evidence that ATLS significantly improves the knowledge of participants managing multiple trauma patients, their clinical skills, and their organization and priority approaches. There is level II-1 evidence that knowledge and skills gained through ATLS participation decline after 6 months, with a maximum decline after 2 years. Organization and priority skills, however, are kept for up to 8 years following ATLS. Strong evidence showing that ATLS training reduces morbidity and mortality in trauma patients is still lacking.
It is highly recommended that ATLS courses should be taught for all doctors who are involved in the management of multiple trauma patients. Future studies are required to properly evaluate the impact of ATLS training on trauma death rates and disability.
我们旨在系统回顾关于高级创伤生命支持(ATLS)课程的教育影响及其对多发伤患者死亡率影响的文献。
研究了1966年至2012年期间Medline、Pubmed和考科蓝图书馆中所有关于ATLS课程的教育影响及其对创伤死亡率影响的英文文章。纳入所有用英文撰写的原创文章。排除调查、综述、社论/信件以及与ATLS课程不同的其他创伤课程或模式。对文章在研究设计、统计分析、结果以及证据的质量和级别方面进行严格评估。
检索共找到384篇文章。其中,阅读了104篇相关文章;23篇符合入选标准并进行了严格分析。10篇原创文章报告了关于ATLS对认知和临床技能影响的研究,6篇文章探讨了通过ATLS培训获得的技能的消退情况,7篇文章探讨了ATLS对创伤死亡率的影响。有I级证据表明,ATLS能显著提高参与者管理多发伤患者的知识、临床技能以及他们的组织和优先处理方法。有II-1级证据表明,通过参与ATLS获得的知识和技能在6个月后下降,2年后下降最多。然而,组织和优先处理技能在ATLS后可保持长达8年。仍缺乏有力证据表明ATLS培训能降低创伤患者的发病率和死亡率。
强烈建议为所有参与多发伤患者管理的医生开设ATLS课程。未来需要进行研究以正确评估ATLS培训对创伤死亡率和残疾的影响。