Hollup Oddvar
Telemark University College, Faculty of Health and Social Studies, Norway.
Int J Nurs Stud. 2014 May;51(5):752-60. doi: 10.1016/j.ijnurstu.2013.09.013. Epub 2013 Oct 6.
International studies have generally defined nursing as a female-dominated occupation. The almost absence of male nurses seems universal, except as a privileged minority occupying positions within nursing specialties ('islands of masculinity'). Nursing is associated with relatively low status owing to gender and income, and is also influenced by cultural perceptions of social status, the nature of the work and sexuality.
This study aims to describe and analyse how gender and cultural perceptions influenced the development of nursing in Mauritius. This paper examines why nursing in Mauritius became gendered in different ways due to the impact of gender equivalence in the work force, the gendered segregation in clinical practice and the absence of caring feminisation in nursing.
This qualitative study is based on in-depth, semi-structured interviews and convenience sampling. The sample includes nurses working at five hospitals. They all come from the central and southern part of Mauritius. The data were collected over a five-month period during 2006.
Individual qualitative interviews were conducted with 47 nurses, both men (27) and women (20), of different grades, ages, religions and ethnic backgrounds.
Nursing practice is gender segregated, influenced and supported by cultural traditions and perceptions of gender relations, sexuality and touch in nursing. However, the professional identity and role is considered non-gendered, implied by the title of 'nursing officer' and the presence of male nurses who constitute almost 50 percent of the work force. Male nurses do not face similar barriers deterring them from entering nursing profession. Nursing did not develop the image of women's work and a low status job in Mauritius.
The nursing profession in Mauritius has been shaped by a different 'history of origin', social, cultural and societal conditions on the basis of the absence of gender imbalance in the work force and caring feminisation in nursing. Moreover, the increase of men's presence in nursing influenced its name, status and perception, shifting nursing into a masculine sphere with advantageous impacts on nursing.
国际研究普遍将护理定义为女性主导的职业。除了作为护理专业领域中占据特权地位的少数群体(“男性气质孤岛”)外,男性护士几乎普遍缺失。由于性别和收入因素,护理的地位相对较低,同时还受到社会地位、工作性质和性取向等文化观念的影响。
本研究旨在描述和分析性别与文化观念如何影响毛里求斯护理行业的发展。本文探讨了由于劳动力性别平等的影响、临床实践中的性别隔离以及护理中缺乏关怀女性化现象,毛里求斯的护理为何以不同方式呈现出性别特征。
本定性研究基于深入的半结构化访谈和便利抽样。样本包括在五家医院工作的护士。他们均来自毛里求斯的中部和南部地区。数据于2006年的五个月期间收集。
对47名不同职级、年龄、宗教和种族背景的护士进行了个人定性访谈,其中男性27名,女性20名。
护理实践存在性别隔离,受到文化传统以及护理中性别关系、性取向和触摸观念的影响与支持。然而,“护理主任”这一称谓以及占劳动力近50%的男性护士的存在,意味着护理的职业身份和角色被认为是无性别之分的。男性护士在进入护理行业时并未面临类似的阻碍。在毛里求斯,护理并未形成女性工作且地位低下的形象。
由于劳动力中不存在性别失衡以及护理中没有关怀女性化现象,毛里求斯的护理行业在不同的“起源历史”、社会、文化和社会条件下得以形成。此外,男性在护理行业中占比的增加影响了其名称、地位和认知,使护理转向男性化领域,对护理产生了有利影响。