Sport, Health and Exercise Research Group, School of Life and Medical Sciences, University of Hertfordshire , UK.
J Sports Sci Med. 2012 Dec 1;11(4):643-52. eCollection 2012.
The Bioharness™ device is designed for monitoring physiological variables in free-living situations but has only been proven to be reliable and valid in a laboratory environment. Therefore, this study aimed to determine the reliability and validity of the Bioharness™ using a field based protocol. Twenty healthy males participated. Heart rate (HR), breathing frequency (BF) and accelerometry (ACC) were assessed by simultaneous measurement of two Bioharness™ devices and a test-retest of a discontinuous incremental walk-jog-run protocol (4 - 11 km·h(-1)) completed in a sports hall. Adopted precision of measurement devices were; HR: Polar T31 (Polar Electro), BF: Spirometer (Cortex Metalyser), ACC: Oxygen expenditure (Cortex Metalyser). For all data, precision of measurement reported good relationships (r = 0.61 to 0.67, p < 0.01) and large Limits of Agreement for HR (>79.2 b·min(-1)) and BF (>54.7 br·min(-1)). ACC presented excellent precision (r = 0.94, p < 0.01). Results for HR (r= ~0.91, p < 0.01: CV <7.6) and ACC (r > 0.97, p < 0.01; CV <14.7) suggested these variables are reliable. BF presented more variable data (r = 0.46-0.61, p < 0.01; CV < 23.7). As velocity of movement increased (>8 km·h(-1)) data became more erroneous. A data cleaning protocol removed gross errors in the data analysis and subsequent reliability and validity statistics improved across all variables. In conclusion, the Bioharness™ HR and ACC variables have demonstrated reliability and validity in a field setting, though data collected at higher velocities should be treated with caution. Measuring human physiological responses in a field based environment allows for more ecologically valid data to be collected and devices such as the Bioharness™ could be used by exercise professionals to begin to further investigate this area.
Bioharness™ 设备旨在监测自由生活环境中的生理变量,但仅在实验室环境中被证明是可靠和有效的。因此,本研究旨在使用基于现场的方案确定 Bioharness™ 的可靠性和有效性。二十名健康男性参与了研究。心率 (HR)、呼吸频率 (BF) 和加速度计 (ACC) 通过同时测量两个 Bioharness™ 设备以及在体育馆中进行的不连续递增走-跑-跑测试(4-11 km·h(-1))来评估。采用的测量设备的精度为:HR:Polar T31(Polar Electro),BF:Spirometer(Cortex Metalyser),ACC:耗氧量(Cortex Metalyser)。对于所有数据,测量设备的精度都报告了良好的关系(r = 0.61 至 0.67,p < 0.01)和较大的 HR (>79.2 b·min(-1)) 和 BF (>54.7 br·min(-1)) 的协议差异。ACC 表现出优异的精度(r = 0.94,p < 0.01)。HR(r=~0.91,p < 0.01:CV <7.6)和 ACC(r > 0.97,p < 0.01;CV <14.7)的结果表明这些变量是可靠的。BF 呈现出更可变的数据(r = 0.46-0.61,p < 0.01;CV <23.7)。随着运动速度的增加(>8 km·h(-1)),数据变得更加错误。数据分析中的数据清理协议消除了明显的错误,随后所有变量的可靠性和有效性统计数据都得到了改善。总之,Bioharness™ HR 和 ACC 变量在现场环境中表现出可靠性和有效性,尽管在较高速度下收集的数据应谨慎处理。在基于现场的环境中测量人体生理反应可以收集更具生态有效性的数据,并且像 Bioharness™ 这样的设备可以被运动专业人员用于开始进一步研究这一领域。