Choi Won Duck, Cho Dong Hyun, Hong Yong Ho, Noh Jae Hyun, Lee Zee Ihn, Byun Seung Deuk
Department of Rehabilitation Medicine, Daegu Fatima Hospital, Daegu, Korea.
Ann Rehabil Med. 2013 Oct;37(5):668-74. doi: 10.5535/arm.2013.37.5.668. Epub 2013 Oct 29.
To evaluate effects of subacromial bursa injection with steroid according to dosage and to investigate whether hyaluronidase can reduce steroid dosage.
Thirty patients with periarticular shoulder disorder were assigned to receive subacromial bursa injection once a week for two consecutive weeks. Ten patients (group A) underwent subacromial bursa injection with triamcinolone 20 mg; another group of ten patients (group B) with hyaluronidase 1,500 IU and triamcinolone 20 mg; and the other ten patients (group C) with triamcinolone 40 mg. We examined the active range of motion (AROM) of the shoulder joint, visual analogue scale (VAS), and shoulder disability questionnaire (SDQ) at study entry and every week until 1 week after the 2nd injection.
All groups showed statistically significant improvements in VAS after 1st and 2nd injections. When comparing the degree of improvement in VAS, there were statistically significant differences between groups C and A or B, but not between groups A and B. SDQ was statistically significantly improved only in groups B and C, as compared to pre-injection. There were statistically significant differences in improvement of SDQ after the 2nd injection between groups C and A or B. Statistically significant improvements in AROM were shown in abduction (groups B and C) and in flexion (group C only).
Repeated high-dose (40 mg) steroid injection was more effective in terms of pain relief and functional improvements of shoulder joint than medium-dose (20 mg) steroid injection in periarticular disorder. Hyaluronidase seems to have little additive effect on subacromial bursa injection for reducing the dosage of steroid.
根据剂量评估肩峰下囊注射类固醇的效果,并研究透明质酸酶是否能降低类固醇剂量。
30例肩关节周围疾病患者被分配接受每周一次的肩峰下囊注射,连续两周。10例患者(A组)接受20mg曲安奈德肩峰下囊注射;另一组10例患者(B组)接受1500IU透明质酸酶和20mg曲安奈德注射;另外10例患者(C组)接受40mg曲安奈德注射。在研究开始时以及每周直至第二次注射后1周,我们检查了肩关节的主动活动范围(AROM)、视觉模拟评分(VAS)和肩关节功能障碍问卷(SDQ)。
所有组在第一次和第二次注射后VAS均有统计学显著改善。比较VAS改善程度时,C组与A组或B组之间存在统计学显著差异,但A组和B组之间无差异。与注射前相比,仅B组和C组的SDQ有统计学显著改善。第二次注射后,C组与A组或B组在SDQ改善方面存在统计学显著差异。AROM在外展(B组和C组)和屈曲(仅C组)方面有统计学显著改善。
在肩关节周围疾病中,重复高剂量(40mg)类固醇注射在缓解疼痛和改善肩关节功能方面比中等剂量(20mg)类固醇注射更有效。透明质酸酶似乎对肩峰下囊注射减少类固醇剂量几乎没有附加作用。