Autoimmun Rev. 2014 Mar;13(3):215-24. doi: 10.1016/j.autrev.2013.10.003.
A wide variety of inflammatory diseases temporally associated with the administration of various vaccines, has been reported in the literature. A PubMed search from 1979 to 2013 revealed seventy one (71) documented cases. The most commonly reported vaccinations that were associated with CNS demyelinating diseases included influenza (21 cases), human papilloma virus (HPV) (9 cases), hepatitis A or B (8 cases), rabies (5 cases), measles (5 cases), rubella (5 cases), yellow fever (3 cases), anthrax (2 cases),meningococcus (2 cases) and tetanus (2 cases). The vast majority of post-vaccination CNS demyelinating syndromes, are related to influenza vaccination and this could be attributed to the high percentage of the population that received the vaccine during the HI1N1 epidemia from 2009 to 2012. Usually the symptoms of the CNS demyelinating syndrome appear few days following the immunization (mean: 14.2 days) but there are cases where the clinical presentation was delayed (more than 3 weeks or even up to 5 months post-vaccination) (approximately a third of all the reported cases). In terms of the clinical presentation and the affected CNS areas, there is a great diversity among the reported cases of post-vaccination acute demyelinating syndromes. Optic neuritis was the prominent clinical presentation in 38 cases, multifocal disseminated demyelination in 30, myelitis in 24 and encephalitis in 17. Interestingly in a rather high proportion of the patients (and especially following influenza and human papiloma virus vaccination-HPV) the dominant localizations of demyelination were the optic nerves and the myelon, presenting as optic neuritis and myelitis (with or without additional manifestations of ADEM), reminiscent to neuromyelitic optica (or, more generally, the NMO-spectrum of diseases). Seven patients suffered an NMO-like disease following HPV and we had two similar cases in our Center. One patient with post-vaccination ADEM, subsequently developed NMO. Overall, the risk of a demyelinating CNS disease following vaccination, although non-negligible, is relatively low. The risk of onset or relapse of CNS demyelination following infections against which the vaccines are aimed to protect, is substantially higher and the benefits of vaccinations surpass the potential risks of CNS inflammation. This does not in any way exempt us from“learning” the lessons taught by the reported cases and searching new and safer ways to improve vaccination techniques and increase their safety profile.
大量文献报道了各种炎症性疾病与各种疫苗接种之间存在时间关联。从 1979 年至 2013 年,在 PubMed 上进行了搜索,共发现了 71 例有记录的病例。与中枢神经系统脱髓鞘疾病相关的最常见疫苗包括流感(21 例)、人乳头瘤病毒(HPV)(9 例)、甲型肝炎或乙型肝炎(8 例)、狂犬病(5 例)、麻疹(5 例)、风疹(5 例)、黄热病(3 例)、炭疽(2 例)、脑膜炎球菌(2 例)和破伤风(2 例)。接种疫苗后发生的中枢神经系统脱髓鞘综合征绝大多数与流感疫苗接种有关,这可能归因于 2009 年至 2012 年期间甲型 H1N1 流感大流行期间接受该疫苗的人群比例较高。通常,中枢神经系统脱髓鞘综合征的症状在免疫接种后几天出现(平均:14.2 天),但也有病例的临床表现延迟(3 周以上甚至接种疫苗后 5 个月)(约占所有报告病例的三分之一)。在临床表现和受影响的中枢神经系统区域方面,接种疫苗后急性脱髓鞘综合征的报告病例存在很大差异。视神经炎是 38 例患者的突出临床表现,30 例为多发性弥散性脱髓鞘,24 例为脊髓炎,17 例为脑炎。有趣的是,相当一部分患者(尤其是流感和人乳头瘤病毒疫苗接种后)脱髓鞘的主要部位是视神经和脊髓,表现为视神经炎和脊髓炎(伴有或不伴有 ADEM 的其他表现),类似于视神经脊髓炎(或更一般地说,NMO 疾病谱)。7 例患者在接种 HPV 后发生了类似 NMO 的疾病,我们中心也有类似的 2 例病例。1 例接种疫苗后发生 ADEM 的患者随后发展为 NMO。总体而言,接种疫苗后发生中枢神经系统脱髓鞘疾病的风险虽然不可忽视,但相对较低。针对疫苗旨在预防的感染,发生中枢神经系统脱髓鞘的风险要高得多,而且疫苗接种的益处超过了中枢神经系统炎症的潜在风险。这绝不能免除我们“吸取”报告病例所提供的经验教训,并寻找新的、更安全的方法来改进疫苗接种技术并提高其安全性。