Stoffel Carina, Lorenz Rosana, Arce Marta, Rico Marina, Fernández Liliana, Imaz María S
Programa de Enfermedades Respiratorias y Tuberculosis de Santa Fe, Ministerio de Salud de la Provincia de Santa Fe, Argentina.
Medicina (B Aires). 2014;74(1):9-18.
Several factors could be responsible for a delay in bacteriological conversion of sputum in patients with pulmonary tuberculosis (pTB) even under proper treatment. We aimed to determine those factors associated with follow-up test compliance and bacteriologic conversion at month two of treatment in patients with pTB who were receiving directly controlled treatment (DOT) in an urban area with low TB burden (notification rate: 14.9 cases/100 000, 2010-2011). We retrospectively analyzed the clinical, demographic, radiological, microbiological and therapeutic characteristics of 196 new smear-positive pTB cases. The proportion of patients who underwent bacteriological examination was 79.1% (155/196) and 74.7% (121/162) at the second and last month of treatment. Smear examinations were significantly more frequent in patients with co-morbidities or receiving DOT in health facilities with laboratory access. Diabetes (OR 17.4, 95% CI 2.0 - 27.0) and high smear grade (OR 13.8, 95% CI 1.8 - 108.0) were highly associated with persistent positive smears. Cavitation (OR 4.6, 95%, CI 1.1 - 20.5) and diabetes (OR 3.3, 95% CI 1.1 - 10.5) were associated with persistent positive cultures. Smear examination results at two months of treatment indicated a sensitivity of 63.9% (23/36) and a specificity of 82.4% (98/119) in relation to culture. The limited predictive value of smear examination relative to culture results indicated the need to find other markers for sputum conversion. Identification of risk factors associated with persistent sputum positivity could contribute to patient care and resource allocation. Prolonged infectiousness in patients with diabetes could indicate the need to review TB control strategies.
即使接受适当治疗,仍有几个因素可能导致肺结核(pTB)患者痰菌转阴延迟。我们旨在确定在结核病负担较低的城市地区(2010 - 2011年报告率:14.9例/10万)接受直接督导治疗(DOT)的pTB患者中,与治疗第二个月的随访检查依从性和细菌学转阴相关的因素。我们回顾性分析了196例新的涂片阳性pTB病例的临床、人口统计学、放射学、微生物学和治疗特征。在治疗的第二个月和最后一个月,接受细菌学检查的患者比例分别为79.1%(155/196)和74.7%(121/162)。合并症患者或在有实验室的医疗机构接受DOT的患者涂片检查频率明显更高。糖尿病(比值比17.4,95%置信区间2.0 - 27.0)和高涂片分级(比值比13.8,95%置信区间1.8 - 108.0)与涂片持续阳性高度相关。空洞形成(比值比4.6,95%,置信区间1.1 - 20.5)和糖尿病(比值比3.3,95%置信区间1.1 - 10.5)与培养持续阳性相关。治疗两个月时的涂片检查结果显示,相对于培养结果,敏感性为63.9%(23/36),特异性为82.4%(98/119)。涂片检查相对于培养结果的预测价值有限,表明需要寻找其他痰菌转阴标志物。识别与痰菌持续阳性相关的危险因素有助于患者护理和资源分配。糖尿病患者传染性延长可能表明需要审查结核病控制策略。