Kahler Bill, Mistry Sonali, Moule Alex, Ringsmuth Andrew K, Case Peter, Thomson Andrew, Holcombe Trevor
University of Queensland School of Dentistry, Brisbane, Australia; Kingston Oral Health Centre, Brisbane, Australia.
University of Queensland School of Dentistry, Brisbane, Australia; Kingston Oral Health Centre, Brisbane, Australia.
J Endod. 2014 Mar;40(3):333-8. doi: 10.1016/j.joen.2013.10.032. Epub 2013 Dec 15.
Recent reviews lament the lack of evidence on the efficacy of regenerative procedures to induce further root maturation despite claims of a paradigm shift in the way infected, necrotic immature teeth with arrested root development can be endodontically treated. The majority of reports are either case series or successful case reports where nonstandardized images may make interpretation uncertain.
This prospective clinical study reports on preliminary outcomes of regenerative endodontic procedures carried out on 16 teeth, 3 mandibular premolars and 13 traumatized central incisors, after 18-month reviews. Qualitative analysis of resolution of periapical radiolucencies and apical closure was undertaken. Quantitative analysis compared preoperative and recall radiographs by using a geometrical imaging program that calculated percentage changes in root length and dentin wall thickness.
Qualitative assessment showed 90.3% resolution of the periapical radiolucency. Apical closure was assessed as incomplete in 47.2% and complete apical closure in 19.4% of cases. Quantitative assessment showed change in root length varying from -2.7% to 25.3% and change for root dentin thickness of -1.9% to 72.6%.
Patterns of continued root maturogenesis were variable at 18-month review. Reviews at 36 months showed continued root maturogenesis for 2 cases. Quantitative analysis can control for changes in angulation but may introduce other measurement errors. However, not all anterior teeth were suitable for TurboReg assessment because overlapping of the cementoenamel junctions and/or further eruption of teeth often precluded stable landmark positioning. Discoloration of the crown was a common consequence, with unaesthetic results in 10 of the 16 cases.
近期的综述对再生治疗诱导牙根进一步发育成熟的疗效缺乏证据表示遗憾,尽管有观点认为,在对感染、坏死且牙根发育停滞的未成熟牙齿进行牙髓治疗的方式上已发生了范式转变。大多数报告要么是病例系列,要么是成功病例报告,其中非标准化的图像可能会使解读存在不确定性。
这项前瞻性临床研究报告了对16颗牙齿(3颗下颌前磨牙和13颗外伤所致的中切牙)进行再生牙髓治疗18个月后的初步结果。对根尖周透射影的消退和根尖闭合情况进行了定性分析。通过使用一个几何成像程序对术前和复查时的X光片进行定量分析,该程序可计算牙根长度和牙本质壁厚度的百分比变化。
定性评估显示,根尖周透射影的消退率为90.3%。在47.2%的病例中,根尖闭合被评估为不完全,19.4%的病例为完全根尖闭合。定量评估显示,牙根长度的变化范围为-2.7%至25.3%,牙根牙本质厚度的变化范围为-1.9%至72.6%。
在18个月的复查时,牙根持续发育成熟的模式各不相同。36个月时的复查显示,有2例牙根持续发育成熟。定量分析可以控制角度变化,但可能会引入其他测量误差。然而,并非所有前牙都适合进行TurboReg评估,因为牙骨质牙釉质界的重叠和/或牙齿的进一步萌出常常妨碍稳定的标志点定位。牙冠变色是常见的结果,16例中有10例外观不佳。