Sullivan J F, Forde J C, Thomas A Z, Creagh T A
Department of Urology and Renal Transplantation, Beaumont Hospital, Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, Dublin 9, Ireland.
Department of Urology and Renal Transplantation, Beaumont Hospital, Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, Dublin 9, Ireland.
Surgeon. 2015 Feb;13(1):15-8. doi: 10.1016/j.surge.2014.02.001. Epub 2014 Mar 6.
To assess the impact of a structured training programme in urethral catheterisation (UC) targeted at newly qualified junior doctors on rates of iatrogenic catheter morbidity within a tertiary care referral centre.
Male UC-related morbidities were retrospectively identified from our computerised inpatient urology consultation system over a 1-year period from July 2010 to June 2011. Relevant medical records were also reviewed. Results were compared with an initial study performed between July 2006 and June 2007, prior the introduction of a structured training programme in our institution. An anonymous questionnaire was used for the subjective assessment of interns about confidence in catheterising post introduction of the programme.
Of 725 urological consultations, 29 (4%) were related to complications arising from male UC during the 1 year period. This reflected a statistically significant decrease when compared to our 2007 figures, 51/864 (6%) (p < 0.05). Again, the most common indication for UC was monitoring urinary output for acute medical illness (19/29, 66%). The most common complication was urethral trauma (16/29, 55%). Of the 29 cases of UC-related morbidity, 18 (62%) resulted from interns performing UC, a decrease of 12% from our original paper. A drop of 27% was seen in the rates of UC related morbidity attributable to interns during the first 6 months of internship (July-December). Overall, 70% (vs 40% original study) of interns felt that their practical training was adequate since introduction of the programme (p < 0.01) with 53% considering theoretical training adequate (vs 16% original study (p < 0.01). When asked were they confident in performing UC, 63% said they were compared to 35% before introduction of the programme (p < 0.05).
UC-related iatrogenic morbidity is not uncommon even in a tertiary-care teaching hospital. Implementation of a structured training programme in UC prior to the commencement of intern year has been shown to result in a significant decrease in the amount of iatrogenic UC related morbidity.
评估一项针对新获得资格的初级医生的尿道插管(UC)结构化培训计划对三级医疗转诊中心医源性插管发病率的影响。
从我们的计算机化住院泌尿科咨询系统中回顾性识别2010年7月至2011年6月这1年期间与男性UC相关的发病率。还查阅了相关医疗记录。将结果与2006年7月至2007年6月在我们机构引入结构化培训计划之前进行的初步研究进行比较。使用一份匿名问卷对实习生在该计划实施后插管信心进行主观评估。
在725例泌尿科咨询中,29例(4%)与1年期间男性UC引起的并发症有关。与我们2007年的数据51/864(6%)相比,这反映出统计学上的显著下降(p<0.05)。同样,UC最常见的指征是监测急性内科疾病的尿量(19/29,66%)。最常见的并发症是尿道创伤(16/29,55%)。在29例与UC相关的发病病例中,18例(62%)由实习生进行UC导致,比我们原来的论文减少了12%。在实习的前6个月(7月至12月),实习生导致的UC相关发病率下降了27%。总体而言,70%(原研究为40%)的实习生认为自该计划实施以来他们的实践培训足够(p<0.01),53%认为理论培训足够(原研究为16%,p<0.01)。当被问及他们对进行UC是否有信心时,63%的人表示有信心,而在该计划实施前这一比例为35%(p<0.05)。
即使在三级医疗教学医院,与UC相关的医源性发病率也并不罕见。已证明在实习年开始前实施UC结构化培训计划可显著降低医源性UC相关发病率。