Elmi P, Reitsma J H, Buschang P H, Wolvius E B, Ongkosuwito E M
Cleft Palate Craniofac J. 2015 May;52(3):327-35. doi: 10.1597/13-143. Epub 2014 May 30.
The aim of this study was to describe directional and fluctuating mandibular asymmetry over time in children with Crouzon or Apert syndrome. Mandibular asymmetry of children between 7.5 and 14 years of age with Crouzon syndrome (n = 35) and Apert syndrome (n = 24) were compared with controls (n = 327). From panoramic radiographs, mandibular directional and fluctuating asymmetry was determined for the three groups. Multilevel statistical techniques were used to describe mandibular asymmetry changes over time. Patients with Crouzon and Apert syndromes showed statistically significant more fluctuating asymmetry for mandibular measures than did controls. Between the Crouzon and Apert syndromes groups, no statistical differences were found in directional and fluctuating asymmetry. The control group showed statistically significantly more directional asymmetry than did patients with Crouzon or Apert syndrome. The controls showed no change over time for the directional asymmetry of condylar-ramal height; however, the directional asymmetry of the gonial angle increased. Patients with Crouzon syndrome showed side dominance for only condylar-ramal height; whereas, patients with Apert syndrome did not show dominance for any of the measurements. Apert and Crouzon syndromes showed developmental instability, in contrast to the controls. No statistically significant longitudinal differences were found for either the directional or the fluctuating asymmetry between Crouzon and Apert syndromes. Findings for fluctuating and directional asymmetry for both syndromes may indicate an inability to cope with genetic and environmental stress during development and treatment, compared with untreated nonsyndromic individuals.
本研究的目的是描述患有克鲁宗综合征或阿佩尔综合征的儿童下颌骨不对称随时间的方向性和波动性变化。将35例7.5至14岁的克鲁宗综合征患儿和24例阿佩尔综合征患儿的下颌骨不对称情况与327例对照组儿童进行比较。通过全景X线片,确定三组儿童下颌骨的方向性和波动性不对称情况。采用多水平统计技术描述下颌骨不对称随时间的变化。与对照组相比,克鲁宗综合征和阿佩尔综合征患者下颌骨测量的波动性不对称在统计学上更为显著。在克鲁宗综合征组和阿佩尔综合征组之间,方向性和波动性不对称方面未发现统计学差异。对照组的方向性不对称在统计学上比克鲁宗综合征或阿佩尔综合征患者更为显著。对照组髁突-升支高度的方向性不对称随时间无变化;然而,下颌角的方向性不对称增加。克鲁宗综合征患者仅在髁突-升支高度上表现出侧别优势;而阿佩尔综合征患者在任何测量指标上均未表现出优势。与对照组相比,阿佩尔综合征和克鲁宗综合征表现出发育不稳定性。克鲁宗综合征和阿佩尔综合征在方向性或波动性不对称方面均未发现统计学上的显著纵向差异。与未经治疗的非综合征个体相比,两种综合征在波动性和方向性不对称方面的结果可能表明在发育和治疗过程中无法应对遗传和环境压力。