Brinda Ethel M, Rajkumar Anto P, Enemark Ulrika, Attermann Jørn, Jacob K S
Department of Psychiatry, Christian Medical College, Vellore 632002, India.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2014 May 7;14:207. doi: 10.1186/1472-6963-14-207.
Lack of state supported care services begets the informal caregiving by family members as the mainstay of care provided to the dependent older people in many Low and Middle Income Countries (LMICs), including India. Little is known about the time spent on caregiving, its cost and the burden experienced by these informal caregivers. We aimed to estimate the costs of informal caregiving and to evaluate the nature as well as correlates of caregivers' burden in a rural Indian community.
We assessed 1000 people aged above 65 years, among whom 85 were dependent. We assessed their socioeconomic profiles, disability, health status and health expenditures. Their caregivers' socio-demographic profiles, mental health, and the time spent on caregiving were assessed using standard instruments. Caregiver's burden was evaluated using Zarit Burden Scale. We valued the annual informal caregiving costs using proxy good method. We employed appropriate non-parametric multivariate statistics to evaluate the correlates of caregivers' burden.
Average time spent on informal caregiving was 38.6 (95% CI 35.3-41.9) hours/week. Estimated annual cost of informal caregiving using proxy good method was 119,210 US$ in this rural community. Mean total score of Zarit burden scale, measuring caregivers' burden, was 17.9 (95% CI 15.6-20.2). Prevalence of depression among the caregivers was 10.6% (95% CI 4.1-17.1%). Cerebrovascular disease, Parkinson's disease, higher disability, insomnia and incontinence of the dependent older people as well as the time spent on helping Activities of Daily Living and on supervision increased caregiver's burden significantly.
Cost and burden of informal caregiving are high in this rural Indian community. Many correlates of burden, experienced by caregivers, are modifiable. We discuss potential strategies to reduce this burden in LMICs. Need for support to informal caregivers and for management of dependent older people with chronic disabling diseases by multidisciplinary community teams are highlighted.
在包括印度在内的许多低收入和中等收入国家(LMICs),由于缺乏国家支持的护理服务,家庭成员的非正式护理成为为依赖他人的老年人提供护理的主要方式。对于这些非正式护理人员花费的时间、成本以及所承受的负担,人们了解甚少。我们旨在估算印度农村社区非正式护理的成本,并评估护理人员负担的性质及其相关因素。
我们评估了1000名65岁以上的人群,其中85人需要依赖他人照顾。我们评估了他们的社会经济状况、残疾情况、健康状况和医疗支出。使用标准工具评估了他们护理人员的社会人口学特征、心理健康状况以及护理所花费的时间。使用扎里特负担量表评估护理人员的负担。我们采用替代商品法估算年度非正式护理成本。我们运用适当的非参数多变量统计方法评估护理人员负担的相关因素。
每周非正式护理的平均时间为38.6(95%置信区间35.3 - 41.9)小时。采用替代商品法估算,这个农村社区的年度非正式护理成本为119,210美元。衡量护理人员负担的扎里特负担量表的平均总分是17.9(95%置信区间15.6 - 20.2)。护理人员中抑郁症的患病率为10.6%(95%置信区间4.1 - 17.1%)。依赖他人照顾的老年人患有脑血管疾病、帕金森病、残疾程度较高、失眠和大小便失禁,以及在帮助日常生活活动和监督方面所花费的时间,均显著增加了护理人员的负担。
在这个印度农村社区,非正式护理的成本和负担很高。护理人员所承受的许多负担相关因素是可以改变的。我们讨论了在低收入和中等收入国家减轻这种负担的潜在策略。强调了需要支持非正式护理人员,以及多学科社区团队对患有慢性致残疾病的依赖他人照顾的老年人进行管理。