Gupta Disha, Jeremy Hill N, Brunner Peter, Gunduz Aysegul, Ritaccio Anthony L, Schalk Gerwin
Wadsworth Center, New York State Department of Health, Albany, NY, USA. Department of Neurology, Albany Medical College, Albany, NY, USA. Early Brain Injury Recovery Program, Burke-Cornell Medical Research Institute, White Plains, NY, USA.
J Neural Eng. 2014 Oct;11(5):056001. doi: 10.1088/1741-2560/11/5/056001. Epub 2014 Jul 31.
Real-time monitoring of the brain is potentially valuable for performance monitoring, communication, training or rehabilitation. In natural situations, the brain performs a complex mix of various sensory, motor or cognitive functions. Thus, real-time brain monitoring would be most valuable if (a) it could decode information from multiple brain systems simultaneously, and (b) this decoding of each brain system were robust to variations in the activity of other (unrelated) brain systems. Previous studies showed that it is possible to decode some information from different brain systems in retrospect and/or in isolation. In our study, we set out to determine whether it is possible to simultaneously decode important information about a user from different brain systems in real time, and to evaluate the impact of concurrent activity in different brain systems on decoding performance.
We study these questions using electrocorticographic signals recorded in humans. We first document procedures for generating stable decoding models given little training data, and then report their use for offline and for real-time decoding from 12 subjects (six for offline parameter optimization, six for online experimentation). The subjects engage in tasks that involve movement intention, movement execution and auditory functions, separately, and then simultaneously. Main Results: Our real-time results demonstrate that our system can identify intention and movement periods in single trials with an accuracy of 80.4% and 86.8%, respectively (where 50% would be expected by chance). Simultaneously, the decoding of the power envelope of an auditory stimulus resulted in an average correlation coefficient of 0.37 between the actual and decoded power envelopes. These decoders were trained separately and executed simultaneously in real time.
This study yielded the first demonstration that it is possible to decode simultaneously the functional activity of multiple independent brain systems. Our comparison of univariate and multivariate decoding strategies, and our analysis of the influence of their decoding parameters, provides benchmarks and guidelines for future research on this topic.
对大脑进行实时监测对于性能监测、交流、训练或康复具有潜在价值。在自然情况下,大脑执行各种感觉、运动或认知功能的复杂组合。因此,如果(a)能够同时从多个脑系统解码信息,并且(b)每个脑系统的这种解码对其他(不相关)脑系统活动的变化具有鲁棒性,那么实时脑监测将最有价值。先前的研究表明,回顾性地和/或孤立地从不同脑系统解码一些信息是可能的。在我们的研究中,我们着手确定是否有可能实时同时从不同脑系统解码关于用户的重要信息,并评估不同脑系统中并发活动对解码性能的影响。
我们使用记录自人类的皮层脑电图信号来研究这些问题。我们首先记录在训练数据很少的情况下生成稳定解码模型的程序,然后报告它们在离线和来自12名受试者(6名用于离线参数优化,6名用于在线实验)的实时解码中的应用。受试者分别然后同时参与涉及运动意图、运动执行和听觉功能的任务。主要结果:我们的实时结果表明,我们的系统能够在单次试验中分别以80.4%和86.8%的准确率识别意图期和运动期(随机预期为50%)。同时,对听觉刺激功率包络的解码导致实际功率包络和解码功率包络之间的平均相关系数为0.37。这些解码器是分别训练并实时同时执行的。
本研究首次证明了同时解码多个独立脑系统的功能活动是可能的。我们对单变量和多变量解码策略的比较以及对其解码参数影响的分析,为该主题的未来研究提供了基准和指导方针。