Erickson Bree, Cooper Timothy, El-Hakim Hamdy
Division of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Department of Surgery, University of Alberta Hospital, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada.
Division of Pediatric Surgery, Department of Pediatrics, Stollery Children's Hospital, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada.
JAMA Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2014 Oct;140(10):927-33. doi: 10.1001/jamaoto.2014.1843.
The classic presentation of laryngomalacia (LM) is stridor, but alternate presentations include snoring and/or sleep-disordered breathing (S-SDB) and swallowing dysfunction (SWD). Several classification schemes have been developed for LM, but to our knowledge, none have been successfully investigated as to the ability to predict parameters of patients with LM or surgical outcomes.
To compare parameters of patients with different types of LM and determine whether the type has prognostic value for surgical outcomes and to explore if any variable predicts or correlates with the type of LM.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: Retrospective case series from a single tertiary pediatric otolaryngology practice. Patients with LM treated with supraglottoplasty (SGP) were eligible. We included patients with confirmed diagnosis of LM who underwent a cold steel SGP and had complete resolution of symptoms or at least 3 months of follow-up, with complete data.
Investigations and treatment of the patients were followed as per routine practice for the senior author (H.E.).
Demographics, type of LM, secondary airway lesions, secondary diagnosis, primary presentation (stridor, S-SDB, SWD), and outcome of SGP were collected. Correlation and multiple regression analysis were performed.
A total of 125 children with LM who underwent SGP for LM were identified. Of these procedures, 119 were cold steel technique, and 8 were repeated procedures. Ninety patients met criteria and were included (mean [SD] age, 1.46 [2.34] years [range, <6 months to 15 years]; male to female ratio, 1.9:1). The primary presentation was stridor in 66 children, S-SDB in 14, and SWD in 10. The type of LM correlated significantly with age (-0.9), and presentation (0.49). Sex and presence of neurological diagnosis (correlation coefficient [SE], -0.317 [0.136], P = .02; and -0.968 [0.361], P <.01, respectively) were associated with outcome. Presentation and obesity were associated with type of LM (-0.251 [0.071], P <.001; and 0.593 [0.296], P = .048, respectively).
Type of LM varies by age and primary presentation. Outcome of management is poorer for males and in the presence of a neurological diagnosis. The findings of the present study may help in counseling parents on the risks and benefits of SGP surgery as well as on expected outcomes postoperatively. Further work is required in validating an existing classification scheme for LM or developing a new, validated classification system with may be used for future outcomes research.
喉软化症(LM)的典型表现为喘鸣,但其他表现包括打鼾和/或睡眠呼吸障碍(S-SDB)以及吞咽功能障碍(SWD)。已经针对LM制定了几种分类方案,但据我们所知,尚未对任何一种方案预测LM患者参数或手术结果的能力进行成功研究。
比较不同类型LM患者的参数,确定类型对手术结果是否具有预后价值,并探讨是否有任何变量可预测LM类型或与之相关。
设计、地点和参与者:来自单一三级儿科耳鼻喉科诊所的回顾性病例系列。接受声门上成形术(SGP)治疗的LM患者符合条件。我们纳入了确诊为LM且接受冷钢SGP并症状完全缓解或至少随访3个月且数据完整的患者。
按照资深作者(H.E.)的常规做法对患者进行检查和治疗。
收集人口统计学资料、LM类型、继发性气道病变、继发性诊断、主要表现(喘鸣、S-SDB、SWD)以及SGP的结果。进行相关性和多元回归分析。
共确定了125例因LM接受SGP的儿童。其中119例采用冷钢技术,8例为重复手术。90例患者符合标准并被纳入研究(平均[标准差]年龄为1.46[2.34]岁[范围,<6个月至15岁];男女比例为1.9:1)。主要表现为喘鸣的儿童有66例,S-SDB的有14例,SWD的有10例。LM类型与年龄(-0.9)和表现(0.49)显著相关。性别和神经诊断的存在(相关系数[标准误]分别为-0.317[0.136],P = 0.02;和-0.968[0.361],P <0.01)与结果相关。表现和肥胖与LM类型相关(分别为-0.251[0.071],P <。则为0.593[0.296],P = 0.048)。
LM类型因年龄和主要表现而异。男性和存在神经诊断时治疗结果较差。本研究结果可能有助于向家长咨询SGP手术的风险和益处以及术后预期结果。需要进一步开展工作以验证现有的LM分类方案或开发一种新的、经过验证的分类系统,可用于未来的结果研究。