Amano Koji, Morita Tatsuya, Tatara Ryohei, Katayama Hirofumi, Uno Teruaki, Takagi Ibuki
1 Department of Palliative Medicine, Palliative Care Team, Osaka City General Hospital , Osaka, Japan .
J Palliat Med. 2015 Mar;18(3):270-3. doi: 10.1089/jpm.2014.0132. Epub 2014 Sep 11.
Palliative care has a positive effect on many clinical outcomes, yet most referrals to palliative care have occurred late. End-of-life (EOL) cancer care has become increasingly aggressive. There have been no studies investigating the association between early palliative care referrals and aggressive EOL care in Japan.
This study was designed to explore the association between early palliative care referrals, inpatient hospice utilization, and aggressiveness of EOL care by investigating cancer decedents.
A retrospective cohort study in a cancer-designated hospital in Japan.
SETTING/SUBJECTS: This study examined 266 consecutive cancer decedents. Inclusion criteria were adults and patients who died from cancer or causes related to cancer. Patients who died from causes unrelated to cancer were excluded. A total of 265 patients met the criteria.
We explored the association between early referrals (>3 months before death) and inpatient hospice utilization and the relationship between the timing of referrals and aggressive EOL care measured by a composite score adapted from Earle and colleagues.
Patients were divided into an early referral group (n=54) and a control group (n=211). The rate of inpatient hospice utilization was significantly higher in the early referral group (74% versus 47%, adjusted p<0.001). While each of six indicators of aggressiveness of EOL care did not differ significantly, the composite score was significantly lower in the early referral group (1.91±0.59 versus 2.14±0.78, adjusted p<0.001).
Early palliative referrals were associated with more inpatient hospice utilization and less aggressive EOL care.
姑息治疗对许多临床结局具有积极影响,但大多数姑息治疗的转诊都发生得较晚。临终癌症护理变得越来越积极。在日本,尚无研究调查早期姑息治疗转诊与积极的临终护理之间的关联。
本研究旨在通过调查癌症死者来探讨早期姑息治疗转诊、住院临终关怀的使用情况与临终护理积极性之间的关联。
在日本一家癌症指定医院进行的回顾性队列研究。
设置/研究对象:本研究检查了266例连续的癌症死者。纳入标准为成年人以及死于癌症或与癌症相关原因的患者。死于与癌症无关原因的患者被排除。共有265例患者符合标准。
我们探讨了早期转诊(死亡前>3个月)与住院临终关怀使用情况之间的关联,以及转诊时间与根据厄尔及其同事改编的综合评分所衡量的积极临终护理之间的关系。
患者被分为早期转诊组(n = 54)和对照组(n = 211)。早期转诊组的住院临终关怀使用率显著更高(74%对47%,校正p<0.001)。虽然临终护理积极性的六个指标中的每一个差异均无统计学意义,但早期转诊组的综合评分显著更低(1.91±0.59对2.14±0.78,校正p<0.001)。
早期姑息治疗转诊与更多的住院临终关怀使用和更少的积极临终护理相关。