Shahidi Shoaleh, Bahrampour Ehsan, Soltanimehr Elham, Zamani Ali, Oshagh Morteza, Moattari Marzieh, Mehdizadeh Alireza
Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Radiology, School of Dentistry, Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Shiraz, Iran.
BMC Med Imaging. 2014 Sep 16;14:32. doi: 10.1186/1471-2342-14-32.
Two-dimensional projection radiographs have been traditionally considered the modality of choice for cephalometric analysis. To overcome the shortcomings of two-dimensional images, three-dimensional computed tomography (CT) has been used to evaluate craniofacial structures. However, manual landmark detection depends on medical expertise, and the process is time-consuming. The present study was designed to produce software capable of automated localization of craniofacial landmarks on cone beam (CB) CT images based on image registration and to evaluate its accuracy.
The software was designed using MATLAB programming language. The technique was a combination of feature-based (principal axes registration) and voxel similarity-based methods for image registration. A total of 8 CBCT images were selected as our reference images for creating a head atlas. Then, 20 CBCT images were randomly selected as the test images for evaluating the method. Three experts twice located 14 landmarks in all 28 CBCT images during two examinations set 6 weeks apart. The differences in the distances of coordinates of each landmark on each image between manual and automated detection methods were calculated and reported as mean errors.
The combined intraclass correlation coefficient for intraobserver reliability was 0.89 and for interobserver reliability 0.87 (95% confidence interval, 0.82 to 0.93). The mean errors of all 14 landmarks were <4 mm. Additionally, 63.57% of landmarks had a mean error of <3 mm compared with manual detection (gold standard method).
The accuracy of our approach for automated localization of craniofacial landmarks, which was based on combining feature-based and voxel similarity-based methods for image registration, was acceptable. Nevertheless we recommend repetition of this study using other techniques, such as intensity-based methods.
传统上,二维投影X线片一直被视为头影测量分析的首选方式。为克服二维图像的缺点,三维计算机断层扫描(CT)已被用于评估颅面部结构。然而,手动地标检测依赖医学专业知识,且过程耗时。本研究旨在开发一款能够基于图像配准在锥束(CB)CT图像上自动定位颅面部地标的软件,并评估其准确性。
该软件使用MATLAB编程语言设计。该技术是基于特征(主轴配准)和基于体素相似性的图像配准方法的组合。总共选择8张CBCT图像作为创建头部图谱的参考图像。然后,随机选择20张CBCT图像作为测试图像来评估该方法。三名专家在间隔6周的两次检查期间,在所有28张CBCT图像中两次定位14个地标。计算并报告手动和自动检测方法在每张图像上每个地标坐标距离的差异,作为平均误差。
观察者内可靠性的组内相关系数合并值为0.89,观察者间可靠性为0.87(95%置信区间,0.82至0.93)。所有14个地标平均误差均<4毫米。此外,与手动检测(金标准方法)相比,63.57%的地标平均误差<3毫米。
我们基于将基于特征和基于体素相似性的图像配准方法相结合的颅面部地标自动定位方法的准确性是可接受的。尽管如此,我们建议使用其他技术(如基于强度的方法)重复本研究。