Cronin Patrick R, Kimball Alexa Boer
50 Staniford St, 7th Fl, Boston, MA 02114. E-mail:
Am J Manag Care. 2014 Jul;20(7):570-6.
To determine if algorithmically generated double-booking recommendations could increase patient volume per clinical session without increasing the burden on physicians.
A randomized controlled trial was conducted with 519 clinical sessions for 13 dermatologists from December 1, 2011, through March 31, 2012.
Sessions were randomly assigned to "Smart-Booking," an algorithm that generates double-booking recommendations using a missed appointment (no-shows + same-day cancella- tions) predictive model (c-statistic 0.71), or to a control arm where usual booking rules were applied. The primary outcomes were the average number and variance of arrived patients per session, after controlling by physician. In addition, physicians received a survey after each session to quantify how busy they felt during that session.
257 sessions were randomized to Smart-Booking and 262 sessions were randomized to control booking. Using a generalized multivariate linear model, the average number of arrived patients per session was higher in the Smart-Booking intervention arm than the control (15.7 vs 15.2, difference between groups 4.2; 95% CI, 0.08-0.75; P = .014).The variance was also higher in the intervention than control (3.72 vs 3.33, P = .38).The survey response rate was 92% and the physicians reported being similarly busy in each study arm.
Algorithmically generated double-booking recommendations of dermatology clinical sessions using individual physician assumptions and predictive modeling can increase the number of arrived patients without overburdening physicians, and is likely scalable to other settings.
确定通过算法生成的双重预约建议能否在不增加医生负担的情况下提高每个临床时段的患者接待量。
2011年12月1日至2012年3月31日,对13名皮肤科医生的519个临床时段进行了一项随机对照试验。
将各时段随机分配至“智能预约”组,该算法使用失约(爽约+当日取消)预测模型(c统计量为0.71)生成双重预约建议,或分配至采用常规预约规则的对照组。主要结局指标为在对医生进行校正后,每个时段到达的患者的平均数量和方差。此外,医生在每个时段结束后接受一项调查,以量化他们在该时段的忙碌程度。
257个时段被随机分配至智能预约组,262个时段被随机分配至对照预约组。使用广义多元线性模型,智能预约干预组每个时段到达的患者平均数量高于对照组(15.7对15.2,组间差异为4.2;95%CI,0.08 - 0.75;P = 0.014)。干预组的方差也高于对照组(3.72对3.33,P = 0.38)。调查回复率为92%,医生报告称在每个研究组中忙碌程度相似。
利用个体医生的假设和预测模型,通过算法生成皮肤科临床时段的双重预约建议,可以增加到达患者的数量,且不会使医生负担过重,并且可能适用于其他环境。