O'Halloran Peter, Scott David, Reid Joanne, Porter Sam
School of Nursing and Midwifery, Queen's University Belfast,Belfast,BT9 7BL,United Kingdom.
Palliat Support Care. 2015 Oct;13(5):1473-86. doi: 10.1017/S1478951514001229. Epub 2014 Oct 22.
Multimedia interventions are increasingly used to deliver information in order to promote self-care among patients with degenerative conditions. We carried out a realist review of the literature to investigate how the characteristics of multimedia psychoeducational interventions combine with the contexts in which they are introduced to help or hinder their effectiveness in supporting self-care for patients with degenerative conditions.
Electronic databases (Medline, Science Direct, PSYCHinfo, EBSCO, and Embase) were searched in order to identify papers containing information on multimedia psychoeducational interventions. Using a realist review approach, we reviewed all relevant studies to identify theories that explained how the interventions work.
Ten papers were included in the review. All interventions sought to promote self-care behaviors among participants. We examined the development and content of the multimedia interventions and the impact of patient motivation and of the organizational context of implementation. We judged seven studies to be methodologically weak. All completed studies showed small effects in favor of the intervention.
Multimedia interventions may provide high-quality information in an accessible format, with the potential to promote self-care among patients with degenerative conditions, if the patient perceives the information as important and develops confidence about self-care. The evidence base is weak, so that research is needed to investigate effective modes of delivery at different resource levels. We recommend that developers consider how an intervention will reduce uncertainty and increase confidence in self-care, as well as the impact of the context in which it will be employed.
多媒体干预越来越多地被用于传递信息,以促进退行性疾病患者的自我护理。我们对文献进行了实证性综述,以研究多媒体心理教育干预的特征如何与引入这些干预的背景相结合,从而帮助或阻碍其在支持退行性疾病患者自我护理方面的有效性。
检索电子数据库(Medline、Science Direct、PSYCHinfo、EBSCO和Embase),以识别包含多媒体心理教育干预信息的论文。我们采用实证性综述方法,对所有相关研究进行综述,以确定解释干预如何起作用的理论。
该综述纳入了10篇论文。所有干预措施都旨在促进参与者的自我护理行为。我们研究了多媒体干预的发展和内容,以及患者动机和实施的组织背景的影响。我们认为7项研究在方法上存在缺陷。所有完成的研究都显示干预措施有小的效果。
如果患者认为信息重要并对自我护理产生信心,多媒体干预可能以易于获取的形式提供高质量信息,从而有可能促进退行性疾病患者的自我护理。证据基础薄弱,因此需要开展研究,以调查不同资源水平下的有效传播模式。我们建议开发者考虑干预措施将如何减少不确定性并增强对自我护理的信心,以及其应用背景的影响。