Shuang Feng, Hou Shu-Xun, Zhu Jia-Liang, Ren Dong-Feng, Cao Zheng, Tang Jia-Guang
Department of Orthopaedics, The First Affiliated Hospital of General Hospital of Chinese PLA, Beijing, China; Department of Orthopedics, The 94th Hospital of Chinese PLA, Nanchang, China.
Department of Orthopaedics, The First Affiliated Hospital of General Hospital of Chinese PLA, Beijing, China.
PLoS One. 2014 Nov 12;9(11):e111695. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0111695. eCollection 2014.
A comprehensive review of the literature in order to analyze data about the success rate of percutaneous resolution of the lumbar facet joint cysts as a conservative management strategy.
A systematic search for relevant articles published during 1980 to May 2014 was performed in several electronic databases by using the specific MeSH terms and keywords. Most relevant data was captured and pooled for the meta-analysis to achieve overall effect size of treatment along with 95% confidence intervals.
29 studies were included in the meta-analysis. Follow-up duration as mean ± sd (range) was 16±10.2 (5 days to 5.7 years). Overall the satisfactory results (after short- or long-term follow-up) were achieved in 55.8 [49.5, 62.08] % (pooled mean and 95% CI) of the 544 patients subjected to percutaneous lumbar facet joint cyst resolution procedures. 38.67 [33.3, 43.95] % of this population underwent surgery subsequently to achieve durable relief. There existed no linear relationship between the increasing average duration of follow-up period of individual studies and percent satisfaction from the percutaneous resolutions procedure.
Results shows that the percutaneous cyst resolution procedures have potential to be an alternative to surgical interventions but identification of suitable subjects requires further research.
全面回顾文献,以分析作为一种保守治疗策略的经皮穿刺解决腰椎小关节囊肿成功率的数据。
通过使用特定的医学主题词和关键词,在多个电子数据库中对1980年至2014年5月期间发表的相关文章进行系统检索。收集并汇总最相关的数据用于荟萃分析,以得出治疗的总体效应大小及95%置信区间。
荟萃分析纳入了29项研究。随访持续时间的均值±标准差(范围)为16±10.2(5天至5.7年)。在接受经皮穿刺解决腰椎小关节囊肿手术的544例患者中,总体上(短期或长期随访后)有55.8 [49.5, 62.08]%获得了满意结果。该人群中有38.67 [33.3, 43.95]%随后接受了手术以实现持久缓解。各研究随访期平均时长的增加与经皮穿刺手术满意度百分比之间不存在线性关系。
结果表明,经皮穿刺囊肿解决手术有可能成为手术干预的替代方法,但确定合适的患者还需要进一步研究。